But it was an emotional time, remember, and Roux, and the Congress
of Buda-Pesth were not assembled to serve truth but to discuss and
to plan and to celebrate the saving of lives. They cared little for
figures then; they cared less for annoying objectors who carped about
comparing figures; they were swept away by Roux’s report of how the
serum cooled fevered brows. Then, Roux could have answered such
annoying critics (with the applause of his famous audience): “What if
twenty-six out of a hundred did die--you must remember that for years
before this treatment _fifty_ out of a hundred died!”
And yet--I, who believe in this antitoxin, I say this, twenty years
after--diphtheria is a disease having strange ups and downs of
viciousness. In some terrible decades it kills its sixty out of a
hundred; then some mysterious thing happens and the virus seems to
weaken and only ten children are taken where sixty died before. So
it was, in those brave days of Roux and Behring, for in a certain
hospital in England, in those very days, the death rate from
diphtheria had gone down from forty in a hundred to twenty-nine in a
hundred--before the serum was ever used!
But the doctors at Buda-Pesth did not think of figures and they
carried home the tidings of the antitoxin to all corners of the
world, in a few years the antitoxin treatment of diphtheria became
orthodox, and now there is not one doctor out of a thousand who will
not swear that this antitoxin is a beautiful cure. Probably they are
right. Indeed, there is evidence that when antitoxin is given on the
first day of the disease, all but a few babies are saved--and if
there is delay, many are lost.... Surely, any doctor should be called
guilty, in the light of what is known, who did not give the antitoxin
to a threatened child. I would be quick to call a doctor to give it
to one of my own children. Why not, indeed? Perhaps the antitoxin
cures. But it is not completely proved, and it is too late now to
prove it one way or another to the hilt, because, since all the world
believes in the antitoxin, no man can be found heartless enough or
bold enough to do the experiment which science demands.
Meanwhile the searchers, believing, are busy with other things--and
I can only hope, if another wave of the dreadful diphtheria of the
eighties sweeps over the world again, I can only hope that Roux was
right.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account