John Carr cast his thoughts back, and there was a sneer upon his thin lips; old Marmaduke had not dealt so successfully with his own son that he need boast. But John did not say it; for many years the name of Robert Carr had dropped out of their intercourse. Had he been dead--and, indeed, for all they heard of Robert, he might be dead--his name could not have been more completely sunk in silence. Marmaduke Carr never spoke of him, and the squire did not choose to speak: he had his reasons. "It was the premium you stuck at, John. We can't put young men out without one, when they get to the age Ben was. _There_ was another folly!--keeping the boy at home till he was twenty years of age, doing nothing except just idling about the land. But it's your affair, not mine; and Ben has certainly gone on a wrong tack this many a year now. I should have discarded him long ago, had he been my son." "I should have felt tempted to do the same," observed the clergyman. "Benjamin has entailed so much trouble on you." "And he'll entail more yet," was the consolatory prediction of old Marmaduke. The squire made no reply. He had his arm on the window-frame supporting his chin, and looking dreamily out. His thoughts were with Benjamin. Why had he not yet discarded this scapegrace son--he, the hard man? Simply because there was a remote corner in his heart where Benjamin was cherished--cherished beyond all his other children. Petty, mean, hard as John Carr was, he had passionately loved his first wife; and Benjamin, in features, was her very image. His eldest son, Valentine, resembled him, the squire; Mrs. Lewis was like nobody but herself; his other children were by a different mother. He only cared for Benjamin. He did not care for Valentine, he did not care for the daughters, but he loved Benjamin; and the result was, that though Ben Carr brought home grief continually, and had done things for which Valentine, had _he_ done them, would never have been pardoned, the squire, after a little holding out, was certain to take him into favour again, and give him another chance. "When does George go out?" asked the squire of Mr. Prattleton, alluding to that gentleman's half-brother, who was nearly twenty years younger than himself. "Immediately. And very fortunate we have been in getting him so good a thing. I hope the climate will agree with him." "Grandpapa," said young Lewis, running up to the squire, "here are two flies coming down the street now. Shall I rush out and secure them first?" "Ask Mr. Carr, my boy. He may like to stay longer, and give a chance to the rain to abate." Mr. Carr, old Marmaduke, laughed. He knew John Carr of old, and his stingy nature. He would not order the flies to be retained lest the payment of them should fall to him. "Go and secure them both, boy," said old Marmaduke; "and there's a shilling for your own trouble."