Modern French Philosophy: a Study of the Development Since ComteGunn, John Alexander
Philosophy
Modern French Philosophy: a Study of the Development Since Comte
Gunn, John Alexander
Philosophy, French; Philosophy, Modern
Fouillée endeavours to unite the purely ideal aspect of ethics—that is
to say, its notion of what ought to be, with the more positive view of
ethics as dealing with what now is. His ethic is, therefore, an attempt
to relate more intimately the twin spheres of Renouvier, _l’état de
guerre_ with _l’état de paix_, for it is concerned not only with what
_is_, but with that which _tends_ to be and which _can_ be by the
simple fact that it is _thought_. As, however, what _can_ be is a
matter of intense interest to us, we are inevitably led from this to
consider what _ought_ to be—that is to say, what is better, or of more
worth or value. The ethical application of the philosophy of
_idées-forces_ is at once theoretical and practical, that philosophy
being concerned both with ideas and values.
As in his treatment of freedom we found Fouillée beginning with the
_idea_ of freedom, so here in a parallel manner he lays down the _idea_
of an end of action as an incontestable fact of experience, although
the existence of such an end is contested and is a separate question.
This idea operates in consciousness as a power of will (_volonté de
conscience_). Intelligence, power, love and happiness-in short, the
highest conscious life—are involved in it, not only for us, but for
all. Thus it comes about that the conscious subject, just because he
finds himself confronted by nature and by over-individual ends,
proposes to himself an ideal, and imposes at the same time upon himself
the obligation to act in conformity with this full consciousness which
is in all, as in him, and thus he allows universal consciousness to
operate in his own individual life. Here we have conscience, the idea
of duty or obligation, accounted for, and the principle of autonomy of
the moral person laid down. The ethical life is shown as the conscious
will in action, finding within itself its own end and rule of action,
finding also the conscious wills of others like itself. Morality is the
indefinite extension of the conscious will which brings about the
condition that others tend to become “me.” Through the increasing power
of intellectual disinterestedness and social sympathy, the old formula
“_cogito, conscius sum_” gives place to that of “_conscii sumus_,” and
this is no mere intellectual speculation, but a concrete principle of
action and feeling which is itself akin to the highest and best in all
religions.
One of the features of this ethic is its insistence upon the primacy of
self-consciousness. Indeed, it has its central point in the doctrine of
self-consciousness, which, according to Fouillée, implies the
consciousness of others and of the whole unity of mankind. Emphasising
his gospel of _idées-forces_, he outlines a morality in which the ideal
shall attract men persuasively, and not dominate them in what he
regards as the arbitrary and rather despotic manner of Kant.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account