Finally there is positive evidence that the Turks borrowed the word
in question from the Greeks; for the time at which they used to fear
the advent of the _karakondjolos_--whether the superstition still
remains the same, I do not know--was fixed not by their own calendar
but by that of the Christians. An article written on the subject of the
Turkish calendar early in last century contains this statement: ‘The
Turks have received this fabulous belief from the Greeks, and they say
that this demon, whom the former call Kara Kondjolos and the latter
Cali Cangheros, exercises his sway of maleficence and mischief from
Christmas-day until that of the Epiphany[583].’ Clearly the Turks would
not have fixed the time for the appearance of the _karakondjolos_ by
the Christian festivals if they had not borrowed the whole superstition
from the Greeks; and indeed the very termination in -ος of the Turkish
form of the word betrays its Hellenic origin.
The proposed Turkish derivation of the word καλλικάντζαρος must
therefore be rejected as finally as Oeconomos’ Latin derivation, and it
remains only to deal with those which treat the word as genuinely Greek.
The first of these is that proposed by Coraës[584], who made the word
a compound of καλός and κάνθαρος. The formation, as might be expected
of so great a scholar, is irreproachable; for the phonetic change of
θ to τζ; is seen in the development of the modern word καντζόχοιρος
(a hedgehog) from the ancient ἀκανθόχοιρος. But the meaning obtained
is less satisfactory. What has a ‘good’ or ‘beautiful beetle’ to do
with a Callicantzaros such as I have described? The question remains
without an answer. And yet some of Coraës’ followers in recent times
have thought triumphantly to vindicate his view by pointing out that in
the dialect of Thessaly ‘a species of large horned beetle’ is known as
καλλικάτζαροι. Now I am aware that elsewhere in Greece stag-beetles are
called κατζαρίδες, which is undoubtedly a modern form of the ancient
κάνθαρος and illustrates once more the phonetic change involved in
Coraës’ derivation; and I can believe that the Thessalian peasantry
with a certain rustic humour sometimes call them καλλικάτζαροι instead.
But what light does this throw on the supposed development of meaning?
The view which these disciples of Coraës appear to hold, namely that
the Callicantzari, who are known and feared throughout Greek lands and
even beyond them in Turkey and in Albania, were called after an alleged
Thessalian species of Coleoptera, would be fitly matched by a theory
that the Devil was so named after a species of fish or a printer’s
assistant or a patent fire-lighter.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account