Modern thinkers and present problems : $b an approach to modern philosophy through its historySinger, Edgar A. (Edgar Arthur)
Philosophy
Modern thinkers and present problems : $b an approach to modern philosophy through its history
Singer, Edgar A. (Edgar Arthur)
Philosophers; Philosophy -- History
“But as for M. Bourdeau, he does not wish to be deceived even
knowingly, and he absolutely repudiates history. He drives her from
his door as deceitful, shameless, dissolute, having sold herself to
the powerful, a courtesan in the pay of kings, an enemy of the people,
wanton and false.”
So far, the picture of non-objective history in all its
ugliness--history as it has been written in the past. But now the
history of the future, objective history, realistic history--ah, that
will be quite another story. It is Bourdeau who speaks: “The historians
of the future will have for their first task the gathering and
interpreting of statistical data concerning the common events of life.
The activity of thought always expresses itself in acts, and the only
way to take account of these is, after having classified them under
definite functions, to set them down at the moment of their happening,
to count them under given conditions of population, of time and place,
then to compare these results whether simultaneous or successive, to
note the variations of the function and to make the inductions that
they warrant. Thus, and only thus, may we some day know what the
multitudes that make up humanity are doing.
“This is the way we must write history from now on, not only in the
young countries which, like Australia, Canada, La Plata, are founded
under new conditions, but even in the old societies of Europe that,
like the others, hope to work out for themselves an ideal order of
labor, of peace and of liberty. For one who has reached our point
of advancement, any other way of studying history is inexact and
childish. A reform is coming, and will either be made by the historians
or in spite of them. The age of literary historiography is about to
close; that of scientific history about to open. When it shall be
able to reconstruct for us the life of a people in the way we have
indicated, we shall see that no story can offer so much of interest, of
instruction and of grandeur.”
I do not know that every one is bound to share Bourdeau’s enthusiasm
for statistical history. Perhaps some will hope with France that they
may not be spared to read history written in this way, and will solace
themselves the meanwhile with their Thucydides and Herodotus. But at
least, all will have caught the martial tread of realism resounding
through these passages.
* * * * *
In the laboratory sciences the objective spirit sits as a strong man
in his castle, impregnable, unattackable. There we see him dreaming
dreams of conquest, the fair domain of history, in which we may include
economics, seems ready to fall to his bow and spear for the world’s
endless betterment. And what lies beyond? Lands that are the fairest,
richest, most desired of all; and yet which will take all his daring,
all his courage, all his steadfastness and an undying enthusiasm to
make his own. They are the lands of morals and religion.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account