Monopolies -- United States; Railroads and state -- United States
When the question of the right to levy taxes upon the people, for the
purpose of building railroads, is before the courts, they decide that
such right exists: First, because the right of eminent domain has been
conferred upon the company; and, second, because the railroads are
public highways; so, that, in every phase the question assumes, the
decisions of the courts are in favor of these corporations, and adverse
to the people.
Notwithstanding the fact that the decisions of the courts fix the status
of the railroad corporations as public in their nature, the real fact
remains that railroads are owned and controlled by private parties, and
it is a mere fiction of law to call them public; and while we accept the
decisions as law, the facts are unchanged. The effect of the legislation
to which we have referred is apparent to all. It has strengthened
corporations, enlarged their powers, and constantly encroaches upon the
rights of the people. So great has this evil become that almost the
entire population of the country, not under the control of or interested
in railroad corporations, are demanding a change of legislation, and
relief from the oppressions heaped upon them by these monopolies.
But the injuries inflicted upon the people by the decisions of the
courts are far greater than those resulting from legislation. By the
decisions of the supreme court of the United States, the distinction
between public and private rights has been obliterated; the constitution
of the country has become of no more binding force than statute laws.
State statutes and the decisions of state courts have been overridden
and annulled where the interests of corporations were to be subserved;
the settled decisions of the same court have been overruled, and a new
doctrine, in conflict with the settled interpretation of the fundamental
law of the land, has been announced, which makes the people the vassals
of railroad corporations. The rights of the people and the states have
been disregarded, and the edicts of the supreme court have been
substituted for constitutional law. By the decree of that court,
railroad corporations are clothed with the attributes of sovereignty,
and the people are compelled to pay taxes to aid in the construction of
their roads. That court has engaged in judicial legislation, and
fastened upon the people a despotic government, with railroad
corporations as their rulers. If it be true that railroad corporations
are public and not private, they are not subject to the control of state
courts or state legislatures. They are not by their charters, or the
powers derived from legislative grants, made public corporations, and if
they are public, they are made so by the decisions of the supreme court,
or by some assumed power not visible to the public eye. It is contended
by some, that if it is fully established that they are public
corporations, the state legislatures and the state courts can regulate
and control them.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account