(620/1. The following series of letters (620-630) refers to the
Melastomaceae and certain other flowers of analogous form. In 1862
Darwin attempted to explain the existence of two very different sets of
stamens in these plants as a case of dimorphism, somewhat analogous to
the state of things in Primula. In this view he was probably wrong,
but this does not diminish the interest of the crossing experiments
described in the letters. The persistence of his interest in this part
of the subject is shown in the following passage from his Preface to the
English translation of H. Muller's "Befruchtung der Blumen"; the passage
is dated February, 1882, but was not published until the following year.
"There exist also some few plants the flowers of which include two sets
of stamens, differing in the shape of the anthers and in the colour of
the pollen; and at present no one knows whether this difference has
any functional significance, and this is a point which ought to be
determined."
It is not obvious why he spoke of the problem as if no light had been
thrown on it, since in 1881 Fritz Muller had privately (see Letter 629)
offered an explanation which Darwin was strongly inclined to accept.
(620/2. H. Muller published ("Nature," August 4th, 1881) a letter
from his brother Fritz giving the theory in question for Heeria. Todd
("American Naturalist," April 1882), described a similar state of things
in Solanum rostratum and in Cassia: and H.O. Forbes ("Nature," August
1882, page 386) has done the same for Melastoma. In Rhexia virginica Mr.
W.H. Leggett ("Bulletin Torrey Bot. Club, New York," VIII., 1881, page
102) describes the curious structure of the anther, which consists of
two inflated portions and a tubular part connecting the two. By pressing
with a blunt instrument on one of the ends, the pollen is forced out
in a jet through a fine pore in the other inflated end. Mr. Leggett has
seen bees treading on the anthers, but could not get near enough to
see the pollen expelled. In the same journal, Volume IX., page 11,
Mr. Bailey describes how in Heterocentron roseum, "upon pressing the
bellows-like anther with a blunt pencil, the pollen was ejected to
a full inch in distance." On Lagerstroemia as comparable with the
Melastomads see Letter 689.) Fritz Muller's theory with regard to
the Melastomads and a number of analogous cases in other genera are
discussed in H. Muller's article in "Kosmos" (620/3. "Kosmos," XIII.,
1883, page 241.), where the literature is given. F. Muller's theory is
that in Heeria the yellow anthers serve merely as a means of attracting
pollen-collecting bees, while the longer stamens with purple or crimson
anthers supply pollen for fertilising purposes. If Muller is right the
pollen from the yellow anthers would not normally reach the stigma. The
increased vigour observed in the seedlings from the yellow anthers
would seem to resemble the good effect of a cross between different
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account