Motherhood and the Relationships of the SexesHartley, C. Gasquoine (Catherine Gasquoine)
Philosophy
Motherhood and the Relationships of the Sexes
Hartley, C. Gasquoine (Catherine Gasquoine)
Mothers; Sex; Women -- Social and moral questions
And here, before I go further, I must again give warning against the
over-hasty view, that men and their uncontrolled passions are alone
responsible. This opinion, once held by me in common with most women, I
have been compelled to give up. Seduction cannot, I believe, be accepted,
without very great caution, as the chief cause of illegitimate births. It
is so comfortable to place the sins of sex on men’s passions. But I doubt
very much if any woman can be made a mother against her own will. I am
inclined to believe that excitement and escape from dulness, as also the
joy in receiving presents, are the principal motives that at first lead
girls into illegal relations.[94]
We find that paternity is acknowledged most frequently in those cases
where the father belongs to a lower social level, where he loses less
by open behaviour. In these classes the man, unless prevented by a
pre-existing tie, usually marries the mother at a later period, and
he does not despise her. The woman’s sin is not as a rule taken too
tragically. If the father of her child does not marry her, it is quite
possible for her to find another husband, who, as a rule, acts as a
father to her love-child. For these reasons the least moral and economic
dangers, alike to the child and its mother, occur when both the father
and the mother belong to the working classes. This is not, however,
always true.
The whole question is a difficult one; the further we inquire, the
more strongly does this appear. We learn that there is no one type of
the unmarried mother, no one cause of the evil of illegitimacy, no one
remedy that will cure it. We cannot wisely be too hopeful. But this is
not an excuse for our indifference. Our system of ignoring this question
and of forcing the unmarried mother into shame, with its incredible
short-sightedness and culpable lack of help and discrimination, is
proved out-of-date, because we now know that it is useless. It does not
prevent illegitimate births, for no law can change the sexual nature of
men and women. As things stand with us at present, honourable or even
decent conduct in illegal sexual relationships has a poor chance of being
cultivated; but those who realise that this is the case are still very
few.
It is because I have come to realise this that I have urged, with all
the power I have, an open recognition of these hidden relationships as
the only way to save them from disgrace and shame. I hope to have made
it clear that I am not thinking of lessening responsibility in asking
for a change in our law. I am not at all advocating any sentimental
legislation; we have had quite enough of that. It is an intelligent
insight that considers causes and their effects that we need to-day in
the administration of our laws.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account