Motherhood and the Relationships of the SexesHartley, C. Gasquoine (Catherine Gasquoine)
Philosophy
Motherhood and the Relationships of the Sexes
Hartley, C. Gasquoine (Catherine Gasquoine)
Mothers; Sex; Women -- Social and moral questions
The sin that the man commits against his wife is being unfaithful. Having
caught the venereal disease is a misfortune. The effect must not be
blamed by itself. Let me illustrate this point of view by considering
a different case. Your child gets scarlet fever by an act of direct
disobedience or sin. He goes to play at a house he has been forbidden
to enter. Would you, because of his sin, refuse to pity and nurse him?
Rather would you not forget his disobedience and desire only to help and
to heal him?
Do you see what I mean now? It is not that I uphold immoral conduct in
the husband or in the lover that I plead thus for pity and understanding
on the part of women.
Few men are intentionally evil. They do not even act foolishly in this
question of infectious disease because they are wantonly careless. Often
they are fully alive to the danger that may result to their wives from
their own infection. I repeat they are not necessarily bad men, and they
may love their wives and children; but they are cowards. All men are
cowards when it comes to facing their wives with their own wrong doings.
If they cannot rely on the pity of their wives, few men will dare to tell
the truth. If they cannot tell the truth, they cannot avoid infecting
their wives. This may lead to the birth of infected children, and who may
say that in this case the crime is the man’s alone? It is to prevent this
crime against the child and against life, that I urge upon women a wiser
and more tolerant attitude.
For greater clearness, I may state the matter thus: there are three
attitudes that may be adopted towards sexual disease. First, that of
the pure moralist, who says only, “This is a sin to be punished.” On
the opposite side is the purely utilitarian, who says, “This is only a
disease to be cured.” But both attitudes may be alike wrong, or, more
correctly, the truth lies midway between the two. The disease, as a
disease, needs to be cured. This is the first step with which nothing
should interfere. But far different and much more complex is the
treatment required to alter the actions that lead to the disease.
As a first step, public opinion ought to condemn too late marriage,
instead of recommending it on economic grounds. The mania for making
economics the centre of life should now surely cease: the falsity of this
view has been exposed by many great writers, but much stronger is the
condemnation that must be given to it by all who can understand the evils
that it has wrought in our sexual lives. Late marriages must be one of
the causes contributing to men’s use of prostitutes before marriage. This
subject has been dealt with already in Chapter XII.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account