Authors, German -- 19th century -- Biography; May, Karl Friedrich, 1842-1912
similarity with the one found in the book of `Job', this is again
just right so, and I am rather to be praised than to be scolded
for that.'"
This shall be the end of this short selection of famous names as
references. What have out most famous authors done without having
suffered such verbal abuse? And what have I done to be treated
like the lowest of all cheaters and thieves? I have, without
thinking much of it, decorated some of my small, Asian tales with
entirely irrelevant geographical and ethnographical arabesques,
which I found in books, which, for a long time, belong to the
public. This is permissable. This is even my right. But what
does Father Pöllmann say to this? He resorts to public
name-calling, saying I was a _"pirate_in_the_field_of_literature,_
_for_all_eternity_the_prime_example_of_a_literary_thief!"_
Emerson, one of the most famous and most noble men of America,
says: "The greatest genius is at the same time also the greatest
borrower." And Goethe says: "Whatever is there, this is mine.
Whether I have taken it from real life or from a book, this is all
the same!" How would Father Pöllmann have to pass an analogous
judgement on these two champions? To him, they would have to be
"for all eternity, the worst among all literary fiends", exuding
the stench of greedy rapacity and moral corruption! A criticism
which is thus ignorant, thus inexperienced, thus self-promoting,
and thus exceeding all limits, as this one, constitutes a danger
not just to literature, but also to the entire people.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account