With the exception of the criticism of John Locke,—if he be the editor of Churchill’s _Collection_,—who wished Hakluyt had condensed more, and of Biddle, who accuses him of perversions in his account of the Cabots (see Mr. Deane’s chapter), the general opinion of Hakluyt’s labor has been very high. Locke’s explanatory catalogue of voyages, which appeared in Churchill, is reprinted in Clarke’s _Maritime Discovery_. Oldys in the _British Librarian_, p. 136, analyzes Hakluyt’s books, and there is a list of them in Sabin’s _Dictionary_ and in the _Carter-Brown Catalogue_, p. 448. An account of the set in the Lenox Library is printed in Norton’s _Literary Gazette_, i. 384. Of the _Divers Voyages_, perfect copies are excessively rare, and the two maps are almost always wanting. The two British Museum copies have them, but the Bodleian has only the Lok map, and the same is true of the Carter-Brown copy (_Catalogue_, p. 290). The other copies in America belong to Harvard College (imperfect), Charles Deane, and Henry C. Murphy. Of the maps, that by Lok is given in reduced fac-simile in the _Carter-Brown Catalogue_ (as also in chapter i. of the present volume), and both are given full size in the reprint of the Hakluyt Society. =1583.= Captain J. Carleill’s little _Discourse upon the entended Voyage to the hethermoste Partes of America_, a tract of a few leaves only, in Gothic letter, was probably printed about this time with the aim to induce emigration and the fixing of commercial advantages. Hakluyt thought it of enough importance to include it in his third volume seventeen years later. _Carter-Brown Catalogue_, p. 292. =1583.= Sir George Peckham’s _True Report of the late Discoveries_, etc. See further on this tract on a preceding page. =1583.= M. M. S. published at London a small tract giving a translation of Las Casas’ story of the Spanish deeds in the New World. _Carter-Brown Catalogue_, p. 293. =1588.= What is called the second original work published in England on the New World is Hariot’s _New Foundland of Virginia_, a small quarto of twenty-three leaves, imprinted at London. Heber had a copy; and Brunet, the first to describe it, took the title from Heber’s Catalogue. There are copies in the Lenox, Huth (_Catalogue_, ii. 652), Grenville (British Museum) and the Bodleian libraries. Sabin, _Dictionary_, viii. 30377, who says this, adds that there was a copy sold surprisingly low at Dublin in 1873, escaping the attention of collectors. It was reprinted at Frankfort in 1590. See chapter iv. =1588.= Appeared an English version of the Latin account of Drake’s voyage.