When Laplace elaborated his hypothesis, heat was considered to be an
imponderable material substance, and continued to be thought of as
such--though perhaps not altogether believed to be so--for somewhere
about half a century afterwards; so that it cannot be wondered at that
he thought the nebula could have been endowed with excessive heat, more
especially as it was looked upon as imponderable, and could in no way
have any effect on the mass of the nebula. He only accepted the idea
that was common to almost all astronomers of his time, that nebulæ were
masses of cosmic matter of extreme tenuity but self-luminous, and
consequently possessed of intense heat; they saw the sun gave light
and felt its heat, and very naturally thought the nebula must be hot
also. Without this idea he could not have formed the hypothesis at
all, because he could not have conceived that the condensation of the
nebula could only take place at its surface, or, as he terms it, "in
the atmosphere of the sun," as most assuredly would be the case with
an excessively hot body. And in order that there may be no doubt about
this being his idea, we quote his own words as guaranteed by M. Faye in
"L'Origine du Monde": "La considération des mouvements planétaires nous
conduit donc à penser qu'en vertu d'une chaleur excessive l'atmosphère
du soleil s'est primitivement étendu au delà des orbes de toutes les
planètes, et qu'elle s'est reserrée successivement jusqu'à ses limites
actuelles." And again: "Mais comment l'atmosphère solaire a-t-elle
déterminé les mouvements de rotation et de révolution des planètes et
des satellites? Si ces corps avaient pénétré profondément dans cette
atmosphère, sa résistance les aurait fait tomber sur le soleil. On
peut donc conjecturer que les planètes ont été formées à ses limites
successives par la condensation des zones de vapeurs qu'elle à dû, en
se refroidissant, abandonner dans le plan de son équateur." Proceeding
on these ideas Laplace was quite in order and logical in conceiving
that successive rings could be abandoned by the hot nebula, through the
centrifugal force of rotation, for the formation of planets, more or
less just in the way we have separated them. Having obtained his end
quite legitimately, as he thought, in this way, he had no occasion to
look any deeper into the affair, and consequently was not under the
necessity of taking any thought of what the interior construction of
the nebula might be, any more than so many others have not done since
his day.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account