In support of our observation--if it needs support--that water as
water cannot penetrate into the earth to a greater depth than where it
meets a temperature of 412° we may refer to reports on earthquakes of
comparatively recent occurrence. We learn from the "London Quarterly
Review" of January 1869, that in the Neapolitan earthquake of 1857, Mr.
Mallett found the greatest focal depth to have been 8-1/8 geographical,
or 9·35 statute miles, which agrees very well with the depth to which
water could penetrate and be suddenly flashed into steam. (We say
nothing, for the present at least, about how the water and the heat
managed to meet so instantaneously.) The shock of the instantaneous
generation of steam might be felt much lower, but it would tend to
interrupt, not to produce, the eruption of lavas. In speaking of the
pressure on the walls of the cavity, where the shock was produced,
being 640,528 millions of tons, the reviewer says, "it may have been
greater because the steam might be supposed to have acquired the
temperature of the lava," and that is 2000°F.; but that could not well
be. In order to meet lava of that temperature the steam would have
to descend to from 20 to 25 miles deep; on the other hand, if the
lava is assumed to have entered the cavity, it could only do so at a
comparatively low velocity and would not reach more than a fraction
of the steam at a time, and even for that reason there could be no
flashing, as steam is only a gas, and cannot be heated otherwise
than as a gas. Here the spirit of facilitating the meeting of the
lava and the steam, is as apparent as in bringing about the meeting
of the water and the lava noticed above. On the whole, therefore, we
think that we were right in saying that steam or water cannot be the
cause of volcanic eruptions, but that the invasion of the domains of
water by the lavas may be the cause, in the main, of the explosive
part of eruptions, and of the most disastrous effects of earthquakes.
Moreover, the focus of the Neapolitan earthquake was 75 miles distant
from Vesuvius, and therefore far removed from anything like direct
connection with the vent of the volcano, so that water from it in any
form could have no effect upon the magmas of scientists.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account