"Let us now consider the alternative theory suggested by Mr. Fisher. He claims that geologists furnish him with a certain amount of positive evidence for the idea that water is an essential constituent of the liquid magma from which the igneous rocks have been derived. Passing over the proofs of the existence of water in the crystals of volcanic rocks, and in the materials of deep-seated dykes, let us come at once to the granite, a rock which can only have been formed at great depths and under great pressures, and which often forms large tracts that are supposed to have been subterranean lakes or cisterns of liquid matter in direct communication with still deeper reservoirs. Now, all granites contain crystals of quartz, and these crystals include numerous minute cavities which contain water and other liquids; and the quartz of some granites is so full of water-vesicles that Mr. Clifton Ward has said: 'A thousand millions might easily be contained within a cubic inch of quartz, and sometimes the contained water must make up at least 5 per cent. of the whole volume of the containing quartz.' This amount only represents the water that has been as it were, accidentally shut up in the granite, for some was doubtlessly given off in the form of steam which made its way through the surrounding rocks." We cannot follow Mr. Fisher in "passing over the proofs of the existence of water in the crystals of volcanic rocks and in the materials of deep-seated dykes"; because the presence of water in these crystals when examined in a laboratory is no proof that water was present in them when they were liquid, and before they put on the form of crystals. There is no analogy between them and General Wade's read. Any crystals that a man can pick up anywhere, even from the mouth of a volcano, are quite capable of absorbing vapour of water from the atmosphere before he can carry them to his laboratory. All matter is supposed to be pervaded, more or less, by the ether, and there is always an open road for it, i.e. the vapour of water to enter by. Nature dives more rapidly into a piece of rock than a man can walk or drive down from the summit of a volcano, so that getting water out of it when he is in his laboratory, is no proof that the water was there when the piece of rock was at the bottom, not the mouth, of the volcano. The minute so-called water-vesicles in granite have only served the purpose of a snare to facilitate his deceiving himself, by the help of Mr. Clifton Ward, to further his speculations. For we think it would have been far more natural for him to have supposed that these vesicles were originally filled with the all-pervading ether. Or, are we to prohibit the ether from being present anywhere, except where it suits us? Even the dimensions given to the vesicles of a thousand millions of them being contained in a cubic inch makes us at once think of something more ethereal than water. And the whole object of Mr.