New Witnesses for God (Volume 2 of 3)Roberts, B. H. (Brigham Henry)
Religion
New Witnesses for God (Volume 2 of 3)
Roberts, B. H. (Brigham Henry)
Book of Mormon; Smith, Joseph, Jr., 1805-1844
Professor J. B. Turner, of Illinois College, Jacksonville, Illinois,
in his "Mormonism in All Ages" (1842), takes practically the same
position, but goes a step further and undertakes to explain how the
Prophet "deceived" the Witnesses, or how he "persuaded" them to
believe, "in some sense," that they had actually beheld "the wonderful
plates." In doing this the professor quotes the revelation given
through the Prophet, in June, 1829, to Oliver Cowdery, David Whitmer,
and Martin Harris, previous to their viewing the Nephite plates. [13]
Also the revelation to Martin Harris in which he is promised that he
shall be a witness to the truth of the Book of Mormon. [14] In the
revelations cited the Lord promises these men that they shall view the
Nephite record; and directs what they shall say after they have seen
and heard the things promised. Because some of the phraseology of these
revelations is found also in the testimony of the Three Witnesses, the
professor rushes to the conclusion that the Witnesses never really saw
the vision, nor heard the voice of God as promised, but were persuaded
to accept these revelations through Joseph Smith as their witness to
the truth of the Book of Mormon. In other words Professor Turner's
theory is that the Witnesses had no other evidence than the word of
Joseph Smith for the existence of the plates and other sacred things
connected with them! And he triumphantly exclaims:
Here, then, is the mighty power of God, the angel, and voice of the
Lord, which revealed such marvels in 1830, all concentrated in the
person, and pouring from the mouth of the Lord's Prophet in 1829. *
* * * The whole, then, of this mighty array of bombast, nonsense,
and blasphemy, resolves itself into this: "Joe Smith is not only
'author and proprietor' of the Book of Mormon, as both he and his
Witnesses declare, but he is also 'power of god,' 'angel,' 'voice,'
'faith,' 'eyes,' 'ears,' and 'hands' for the Witnesses themselves;
that is, all the evidence the world has for the Book of Mormon,
after all this bluster, is 'Joe Smith's say so.' He says that
God instructs him, he instructs the Witnesses and the Witnesses
instruct the world. _Quod erat demonstradum_!" (p. 179.)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account