New Witnesses for God (Volume 3 of 3)Roberts, B. H. (Brigham Henry)
Religion
New Witnesses for God (Volume 3 of 3)
Roberts, B. H. (Brigham Henry)
Book of Mormon; Smith, Joseph, Jr., 1805-1844
In the distribution of bread and wine at this high festival, [the
feast of Raymi] the orthodox Spaniards who first came into the
country saw a striking resemblance to the Christian communion;
as in the practice of confession and penance, which, in a most
irregular form indeed, seems to have been used by the Peruvians,
they discerned a coincidence with another of the sacraments of the
Church. The good fathers were fond of tracing such coincidences,
which they considered as the contrivance of Satan, who thus
endeavored to delude his victims by counterfeiting the blessed
rites of Christianity. Others, in a different vein, imagined that
they saw in such analogies the evidence that some of the primitive
teachers of the gospel, perhaps an apostle himself, had paid a
visit to these distant regions and scattered over them the seeds of
religious truth. But it seems hardly necessary to invoke the Prince
of Darkness, or the intervention of the blessed saints to account
for coincidences which have existed in countries far removed from
the light of Christianity, and in ages, indeed, when its light had
not yet risen on the world. It is much more reasonable to refer
such casual points of resemblance to the general constitution of
man and the necessities of his moral nature. [19]
Of which I think De Roo very justly remarks: "The Christian mysteries
admitted by the ancient Peruvians and Mexicans could hardly find
their origin in man's constitution; nor are religious practices, like
baptism, fasting, celibacy, and a cloistered life, to be considered
as necessities of man's moral, yet corrupt nature. More reasonable and
better historical causes should be found to account for the presence of
Christian faith and Christian rites in ancient America." [20]
H. H. Bancroft also concedes the existence of rites among native
Americans analogous to those existing among Jews and Christians, but
regards them as mere coincidences. He says:
Many rites and ceremonies were found to exist among the civilized
nations of America that were very similar to certain others
observed by the Jews and Christians in the old world. The
innumerable speculators on the origin of the aboriginal inhabitants
of the new world, or at least on the origin of their civilization,
have not neglected to bring forward these coincidences--there is
no good reason to suppose them anything else--in support of their
various theories. [21]
On which De Roo remarks: "Coincidences, so many, so striking, in faith,
in morals, and liturgy! Coincidences, indeed, little short of wonders!"
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account