Niebuhr's lectures on Roman history, Vol. 3 (of 3)Niebuhr, Barthold Georg
History
Niebuhr's lectures on Roman history, Vol. 3 (of 3)
Niebuhr, Barthold Georg
Rome -- History
Seneca is a man of real genius, which after all is the main thing: his
influence upon literature has been a most beneficial one; and this I say
the more readily, as I dislike him so much. The opinion Dio Cassius
gives of him, has a great deal in it which is true and correct; but it
is exaggerated, and much too bitter. His affected and sentimental style,
strikingly reminds one of a French school, of which Rousseau and Buffon
were the founders, and which owing to its faults would be quite
unbearable, had it not originated from men of such transcendent talent.
Seneca, however, is not to be compared with either of them for loftiness
of intellect. _Diderot’s Essai sur le règne de Claude et de Néron_, is a
very remarkable book, and the contrast between him and Dio Cassius is
highly interesting: his too was a very ingenious mind, and his manner
was like that of Seneca, as he also was but the creature of his age. In
the time of Nero, lived Lucan, whose poetry is of the school of Seneca,
a striking proof how much more intolerable this mannerism is in poetry
than in prose. Bernardin de St. Pierre and Chateaubriand are of the same
school: it would be still more bearable, did it not always fall into
moralizing sentimentality, which is the case with the former, whilst
Chateaubriand is neither more nor less than a bad Lucan. The latter kept
his ground until late in the middle ages, and was immensely read, almost
as much as Virgil: people were divided into the Virgilian and Lucanian
school. The true restorator of good taste in Rome was Quintilian, who is
by no means to be reckoned as one of the _argentea ætas_. With that
insupportable mannerism Nero also was tainted; whose talent no one can
deny, but who, wherever he was not a fiend, showed himself strange and
wrong-headed. In prose the same tone pervaded history also: Fabius
Rusticus, who was so much read, has undoubtedly written likewise in the
Annæan manner.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account