Novum organon renovatum: Being the second part of the philosophy of the inductive sciencesWhewell, William
Philosophy
Novum organon renovatum: Being the second part of the philosophy of the inductive sciences
Whewell, William
Science -- Philosophy
6. In fact, these forces--mechanical, chemical and vital,--as we
advance from one to the other, each bring into our consideration new
characters; and what these characters are, has appeared in the
historical survey which we made of the Fundamental Ideas of the
various sciences. It was then shown that the forces by which
chemical effects are produced necessarily involve the Idea of
Polarity,--they are polar forces; the particles tend together in
virtue of opposite properties which in the combination neutralize
each other. Hence, in attempting to advance to a theory of Causes in
chemistry, our task is by no means to invent laws of _mechanical_
force, and collections of forces, by which the effects may be
produced. We know beforehand that no such attempt can succeed. Our
aim must be to conceive such new kinds of force, including Polarity
among their characters, as may best render the results intelligible.
7. Thus in advancing to a Science of Cause in any subject, the
labour and the struggle is, not to analyse the phenomena according
to any preconceived and already familiar ideas, but to form
distinctly new conceptions, such as do really carry us to a more
intimate view of the processes of nature. Thus in the case of
astronomy, the obstacle which deferred the discovery of the true
causes from the time of Kepler to that of Newton, was the difficulty
of taking hold of mechanical conceptions and axioms with sufficient
clearness and steadiness; which, during the whole of that interval,
mathematicians were learning to do. In the question of causation
which now lies most immediately in the path of science, that of the
causes of electrical and chemical phenomena, the business of rightly
fixing and limiting the conception of polarity, is the proper object
of the efforts of discoverers. Accordingly a large portion of Mr
Faraday's recent labours[23\2] is directed, not to {123} the attempt
at discovering new laws of phenomena, but to the task of throwing
light upon the conception of polarity, and of showing how it must be
understood, so that it shall include electrical induction and other
phenomena, which have commonly been ascribed to forces acting
mechanically at a distance. He is by no means content, nor would it
answer the ends of science that he should be, with stating the
results of his experiments; he is constantly, in every page,
pointing out the interpretation of his experiments, and showing how
the conception of Polar Forces enters into this interpretation. 'I
shall,' he says[24\2], 'use every opportunity which presents itself
of returning to that strong test of truth, experiment; but,' he
adds, 'I shall necessarily have occasion to speak theoretically, and
even hypothetically.' His hypothesis that electrical inductive
action always takes place by means of a continuous line of polarized
particles, and not by attraction and repulsion at a distance, if
established, cannot fail to be a great step on our way towards a
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account