Novum organon renovatum: Being the second part of the philosophy of the inductive sciencesWhewell, William
Philosophy
Novum organon renovatum: Being the second part of the philosophy of the inductive sciences
Whewell, William
Science -- Philosophy
and trihedral angles, which occur in solid geometry. Yet how
absolutely necessary is a perfect mastery of such reasonings, to him
who is to explain the motions of the moon in {166} latitude and
longitude! How necessary, again, is the same faculty to the student
of crystallography! Without mathematical habits of conception and of
thinking, these portions of science are perfectly inaccessible. But
the early study of plane and solid geometry gives to all tolerably
gifted persons, the habits which are thus needed. The discipline of
following the reasonings of didactic works on this subject, till we
are quite familiar with them, and of devising for ourselves
reasonings of the same kind, (as, for instance, the solutions of
problems proposed,) soon gives the mind the power of _discoursing_
with perfect facility concerning the most complex and multiplied
relations of space, and enables us to refer to the properties of all
plane and solid figures as surely as to the visible forms of
objects. Thus we have here a signal instance of the efficacy of
education in giving to our Conceptions that clearness, which the
formation and existence of science indispensably require.
[Note 13\3: See _Hist. Sc. Ideas_, b. ii. c. xiii.]
2. It is not my intention here to enter into the details of the form
which should be given to education, in order that it may answer the
purposes now contemplated. But I may make a remark, which the above
examples naturally suggest, that in a mathematical education,
considered as a preparation for furthering or understanding physical
science, Geometry is to be cultivated, far rather than Algebra:--the
properties of space are to be studied and reasoned upon as they are
in themselves, not as they are replaced and disguised by symbolical
representations. It is true, that when the student is become quite
familiar with elementary geometry, he may often enable himself to
deal in a more rapid and comprehensive manner with the relations of
space, by using the language of symbols and the principles of
symbolical calculation: but this is an ulterior step, which may be
added to, but can never be substituted for, the direct cultivation
of geometry. The method of symbolical reasoning employed upon
subjects of geometry and mechanics, has certainly achieved some
remarkable triumphs in the treatment of the theory of the universe.
These successful {167} applications of symbols in the highest
problems of physical astronomy appear to have made some teachers of
mathematics imagine that it is best to _begin_ the pupil's course
with such symbolical generalities. But this mode of proceeding will
be so far from giving the student clear ideas of mathematical
relations, that it will involve him in utter confusion, and probably
prevent his ever obtaining a firm footing in geometry. To commence
mathematics in such a way, would be much as if we should begin the
study of a language by reading the highest strains of its lyrical
poetry.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account