Novum organon renovatum: Being the second part of the philosophy of the inductive sciencesWhewell, William
Philosophy
Novum organon renovatum: Being the second part of the philosophy of the inductive sciences
Whewell, William
Science -- Philosophy
THE inconveniences arising from the want of a good Nomenclature were
long felt in Botany, and are still felt in Mineralogy. The attempts
to remedy them by _Synonymies_ are very ineffective, for such
comparisons of synonyms do not supply a systematic nomenclature; and
such a one alone can enable us to state general truths respecting
the objects of which the classificatory sciences treat. The _System_
and the _Names_ ought to be introduced together; for the former is a
collection of asserted analogies and resemblances, for which the
latter provide simple and permanent expressions. Hence it has
repeatedly occurred in the progress of Natural History, that good
Systems did not take root, or produce any lasting effect among
naturalists, because they were not accompanied by a corresponding
Nomenclature. In this way, as we have already noticed, the excellent
botanical System of Cæsalpinus was without immediate effect upon the
science. The work of Willoughby, as Cuvier says[26\4], forms an
epoch, and {288} a happy epoch in Ichthyology; yet because Willoughby
had no Nomenclature of his own, and no fixed names for his genera,
his immediate influence was not great. Again, in speaking of
Schlotheim's work containing representations of fossil vegetables,
M. Adolphe Brongniart observes[27\4] that the figures and
descriptions are so good, that if the author had established a
nomenclature for the objects he describes, his work would have
become the basis of all succeeding labours on the subject.
[Note 26\4: _Hist. des Poissons_, Pref.]
[Note 27\4: _Prodrom. Veg. Foss._ p. 3.]
As additional examples of cases in which the improvement of
classification, in recent times, has led philosophers to propose new
names, I may mention the term _Pœcilite_, proposed by Mr. Conybeare
to designate the group of strata which lies below the oolites and
lias, including the new red or variegated sandstone, with the keuper
above, and the magnesian limestone below it. Again, the transition
districts of our island have recently been reduced to system by
Professor Sedgwick and Mr. Murchison; and this step has been marked
by the terms _Cambrian_ system, and _Silurian_ system, applied to
the two great groups of formations which they have respectively
examined, and by several other names of the subordinate members of
these formations.
Thus System and Nomenclature are each essential to the other.
Without Nomenclature, the system is not permanently incorporated
into the general body of knowledge, and made an instrument of future
progress. Without System, the names cannot express general truths,
and contain no reason why they should be employed in preference to
any other names.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account