The healthy peasant, who rises with the sun, and breathes the free
air of his native hills, may and will feel all the infliction of
confinement, which, while it chains his limbs, stagnates his faculties.
Not so the sedentary and solitary man of letters. Your cell becomes
_his_ study: the window may be somewhat narrower--the lattice, that was
wont to open to the climbing honeysuckle, may now be barred with its
iron stanchions; but he soon forgets this. “His mind to him a palace
is,” wherein he dwells at peace. Now, to put them on something of a par,
I have a suggestion to make to the legislature, which I shall condense
as briefly as possible. Never sentence your man of education, whatever
his offence, to solitary confinement; but condemn him to dine out, in
Dublin, for seven or fourteen years--or, in murder cases, for the term
of his natural life. For slight offences, a week's dinners, and a few
evening parties might be sufficient--while old offenders and bad cases,
might be sent to the north side of the city.
It may be objected to this--that insanity, which so often occurs in the
one case, would supervene in the other; but I rather think not. My own
experience could show many elderly people of both sexes, long inured to
this state, who have only fallen into a sullen and apathetic fatuity;
but who, bating deafness and a look of dogged stupidity, are still
reasoning beings--what they once were, it is hard to say.
But I take the man who, for some infraction of the law, is suddenly
carried away from his home and friends--the man of mind, of reading, and
reflection. Imagine him, day after day, beholding the everlasting saddle
of mutton--the eternal three chickens, with the tongue in the midst
of them; the same travesty of French cookery that pervades the
side-dishes--the hot sherry, the sour Moselle: think of him, eating out
his days through these, unchanged, unchangeable--with the same _cortege_
of lawyers and lawyers' wives--doctors, male and female--surgeons,
subalterns, and, mayhap, attorneys: think of the old jokes he has been
hearing from childhood still ringing in his ears, accompanied by the
same laugh which he has tracked from its burst in boyhood to its last
cackle in dotage: behold him, as he sits amid the same young ladies,
in pink and blue, and the same elderly ones, in scarlet and purple;
see him, as he watches every sign and pass-word that have marked these
dinners for the long term of his sentence, and say if his punishment be
not indeed severe.
Then think how edifying the very example of his suffering, as, with pale
cheek and lustreless eye--silent, sad, and lonely--he sits there! How
powerfully such a warning must speak to others, who, from accident or
misfortune, may be momentarily thrown in his society.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account