Old-Time Makers of Medicine: The Story of The Students And Teachers of the Sciences Related to Medicine During the Middle AgesWalsh, James J. (James Joseph)
History
Old-Time Makers of Medicine: The Story of The Students And Teachers of the Sciences Related to Medicine During the Middle Ages
Walsh, James J. (James Joseph)
Medicine, Medieval; Physicians
new enthusiasm and better methods, which, caught on the rising
wave of interest in medical teaching at Bologna, and preserved
by his own energy as a writer in the first original systematic
treatise written since the time of Galen, created for him in
subsequent uncritical times the reputation of being the
Restorer of the practice of anatomizing the human body, the
first one to demonstrate and teach such knowledge since the
time of the Ptolemaic anatomists, Erasistratus and Herophilus.
"The changes have been rung by medical historians upon a
casual reference in Mondino's chapter on the uterus to the
bodies of two women and one sow which he had dissected, as if
these were the first and the only cadavers dissected by him.
The context involves no such construction. He is enforcing a
statement that the size of the uterus may vary, and to
illustrate it remarks that 'a woman whom I anatomized in the
month of January last year, viz., 1315 Anno Christi, had a
larger uterus than one whom I anatomized in the month of March
of the same year.' And further, he says that 'the uterus of a
sow which I dissected in 1316 (the year in which he was
writing) was a hundred times greater than any I have seen in
the human female, for she was pregnant and contained thirteen
pigs.' These happen to be the only reference to specific
bodies that he makes in his treatise. But it is a far cry to
wring out of these references the conclusion that these are
the only dissections he made. It is quite true that if we
incline to enshroud his work in a cloud of mystery and to
figure it as an unprecedented awe-inspiring feature to break
down the prejudices of the ages, it is easy to think of him as
having timidly profaned the human body by his anatomizing zeal
in but one or two instances. His own language, however,
throughout his book is that of a man who was familiar with the
differing conditions of the organs found in many different
bodies; a man who was habitually dissecting."
(Quotations from the work of Mundinus showing his familiarity
with dissections. The leaf and line references are to the
Dryander edition, Marburg, 1541.)
"I do not consider separately the anatomy of component parts,
because their anatomy does not appear clearly in the fresh
subject, but rather in those macerated in water." (Leaf 2,
lines 8-13.)
"... these differences are more noticeable in the cooked or
perfectly dried body, and so you need not be concerned about
them, and perhaps I will make an anatomy upon such a one at
another time and will write what I shall observe with my own
senses, as I have proposed from the beginning." (Leaf 60,
lines 14-17.)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account