In criticising Cromwell, however, we must remember that generally in
such cases an even greater share of blame must attach to the nation than
to the man. Free government is only for nations that deserve it; and
they lose all right to it by licentiousness, no less than by servility.
If a nation cannot govern itself, it makes comparatively little
difference whether its inability springs from a slavish and craven
distrust of its own powers, or from sheer incapacity on the part of its
citizens to exercise self-control and to act together. Self-governing
freemen must have the power to accept necessary compromises, to make
necessary concessions, each sacrificing somewhat of prejudice, and even
of principle, and every group must show the necessary subordination of
its particular interests to the interests of the community as a whole.
When the people will not or cannot work together; when they permit
groups of extremists to decline to accept anything that does not
coincide with their own extreme views; or when they let power slip from
their hands through sheer supine indifference; then they have themselves
chiefly to blame if the power is grasped by stronger hands. Yet, while
keeping all this in mind, it must not be forgotten that a great and
patriotic leader may, if the people have any capacity for
self-government whatever, help them upwards along their hard path by his
wise leadership, his wise yielding to even what he does not like, and
his wise refusal to consider his own selfish interests. A people
thoroughly unfit for self-government, as were the French at the end of
the eighteenth century, are the natural prey of a conscienceless tyrant
like Napoleon. A people like the Americans of the same generation can be
led along the path of liberty and order by a Washington. The English
people, in the middle of the seventeenth century, might have been helped
to entire self-government by Cromwell, but were not sufficiently
advanced politically to keep him from making himself their absolute
master if he proved morally unequal to rising to the Washington level;
though doubtless they would not have tolerated a man of the Napoleonic
type.
[Illustration:
Oliver Cromwell.
From the painting at Althorp by Robert Walker.
By permission of Earl Spencer, K.G.
]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account