In England, Cromwell stood for religious toleration, so far as he was
able. Fanatics who thought themselves incarnations of the Saviour, or
prophets of a new dispensation, or who indulged in indecent or seditious
conduct, or who disturbed the public peace by breaking into regular
churches, of course had to be suppressed. Nowadays, most offenders of
this type would be ignored, and, if not, they would simply be arrested
by the police, in the course of the ordinary exercise of the police
power, just as any other disturbers of the peace are arrested. In those
days, however, such offenders would have been punished with death in
Spain, Italy, or Austria; and, indeed, in most continental countries. In
the England of Cromwell, they were merely temporarily imprisoned. The
attitude of mind, both of the public generally and of the best and most
religious people, toward Unitarians, Socinians, and those who would
nowadays be called Free-Thinkers, was purely mediæval; and even Cromwell
could only moderate the persecution to which they were subjected. But
these were minor exceptions. For the majority of the people in England,
there was religious liberty; and for the bulk of the minority, though
there was not complete religious liberty, there was a nearer approach to
it than obtained in Continental Europe.
In Ireland, on the other hand, the public exercise of the faith of the
enormous majority was prohibited, and their religious teachers expelled.
There is a popular belief that under Cromwell all Irishmen were expelled
from three-fourths of the island, and driven into Connaught, their
places being taken by English and Scotch immigrants. While exceedingly
cruel, this would have been an understandable policy, and would have
resulted in the substitution of one race and one creed for another race
and another creed throughout the major part of the island. What was
actually done, however, combined cruelty with ultimate inefficiency; it
caused great immediate suffering, while perpetuating exactly the
conditions against which it was supposed to provide. The Catholic
landholders were, speaking generally, driven into Connaught, and the
priests expelled, while the peasants, laborers, and artisans were left
as they were, but of course deprived of all the leadership which could
give them a lift upward. In Ulster there had been a considerable
substitution of one race for the other, among the actual tillers and
occupiers of the soil. Under Cromwell, the change elsewhere consisted in
the bringing in of alien landlords. In other words, to the already
existing antagonism of race, creed, and speech, was added the antagonism
of caste. The property-holder, the landlord, the man of means, was an
Englishman by race and speech, and a Protestant by faith; while the mass
of the laborers roundabout him were Catholic Celts who spoke Erse. Ultra
admirers of Cromwell and the Puritans have actually spoken as if this
plan, provided only that it had been allowed to work long enough, would
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account