Olympic Victor Monuments and Greek Athletic ArtHyde, Walter Woodburn
History
Olympic Victor Monuments and Greek Athletic Art
Hyde, Walter Woodburn
Olympics; Sculpture, Greek; Sports -- Greece
These differences are most apparent in the surface modeling and facial
expression of the two works. In the _Agias_ the muscles are not
over-emphasized in detail, but show the simple observation of nature
characteristic of artists who worked before the scientific study of
anatomy at the Museum of Alexandria had reacted upon sculpture. In the
_Apoxyomenos_, on the other hand, we see an intentional display of the
new learning in the labored and detailed treatment of the muscles,
which disclose a knowledge of anatomy unknown before the Hellenistic
age. This academic treatment, culminating later in such realistic works
as the _Laocoön_ and the _Farnese Herakles_, can hardly have antedated
the beginning of the third century B. C., when anatomy was studied by
the physicians Herophilos and Erasistratos, a date after the close
of the activity of Lysippos. We see no trace of this influence in
the _Agias_. Moreover, the face of the latter discloses the intense
expression, which is elsewhere seen only in works supposed to be by,
or influenced by, Skopas, which recalls what Plutarch[2040] said of
Lysippos’ portraits of Alexander, that they reproduced his masculine
and leonine air (αὐτοῦ τὸ ἀρρενωπὸν καὶ λεοντῶδες); for a comparison
of this face with that of the _Apoxyomenos_, which exhibits the
lifelessness and lack of expression so characteristic of many early
Hellenistic works, makes it still more evident that we must be on our
guard against assuming that both works are representative of the same
sculptor. The essential differences in physical type and artistic
execution between the two statues have been well summarized by K. T.
Frost in a letter published by Prof. Percy Gardner in the latter’s
treatment of the same subject.[2041] After a careful analysis of these
differences, Frost closes by saying: “It is difficult to believe that
the two statues represent works by the same artist; it is not only
the type of man, but the way in which that type is expressed which
forms the contrast.” He compares the _Apoxyomenos_ with the _Borghese
Warrior_ (Fig. 43) as true products of the Hellenistic age.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account