The chief harm done by prettiness in art is that it confirms the
multitude in their dulness instead of arousing them from it. What
the “man in the street” feels in presence of a work of Bouguereau’s
is self-complacent pleasure at the artist agreeing with him. He
will expect the same feeling also from real works of art, and be
disappointed if he fails to find it. Pretty paintings deaden the mind
of the average man for powerful works, which teach men to see, educate
eyes, operate for cataract, and heal colour-blindness, are keys to the
hidden sense of lines of movement, interpret the symbolism of form,
and point the way to unknown beauty. The bloodthirsty backwoodsman
of Montmartre is, therefore, right to think little or nothing of
Bouguereau, and to scalp him; and the Philistine who expects to elevate
and enrich his mind by art must make the sacrifice of renouncing the
cheap pleasure which the engaging banality of prettiness procures him.
If Bouguereau has anything personal to say, he can say it no worse than
many another. His “Portrait of Himself” in the velvet painting-jacket
is sincere, and at any rate strives to be honest. It is true that here,
too, he has not been quite able to overcome his habit of embellishing,
and his cheeks are distressingly rosy. One could not expect from
him the almost terrifying inexorableness with which a David has
confessed the dreadful grimace of his face paralysed on one side, and
a Rembrandt, in his old age, the puffiness of his features and the
wateriness of his eyes. These men had such a pride in truthfulness
that, in their anxiety not to be partial, they felt almost hostile to
themselves, and tried, and judged themselves accordingly. Bouguereau
does not understand why he should treat himself more ill-temperedly
than his Cupids and nymphs, and smiles good-humouredly at himself.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account