Beside these excellent details, many middling and absolute weak
ones disturb us. The dead husband in the grave has an Aztec face
of repulsive ugliness, which is not called for by any artistic
considerations. The attitudes of many figures, especially those
squatting or cowering, are in bad taste. A primary personage—the man
who has stepped into the Gate of Death—stalks bending forward with
head bowed down and the muscles of his back contracted, like one
who is hauling with all his might. It is a matter of surprise that
the tow-rope with which the vessel is dragged is not to be seen. I
cannot prove it, but I am convinced that Bartholomé has formed this
man, not after a model, but from what he recollected of a hauler by
Constantin Meunier. I have already called attention to the monotony
of the group _motifs_. The whole conception of the composition, at
any rate of the upper story, is an echo of Canova’s monument to Maria
Christina at Vienna, with the further development that Bartholomé
shows the subterrestrial and supernatural continuation of the theme
which Canova carries only as far as the entrance to the realm of
shades, leaving what follows to the pious belief of the spectator. The
weightiest objection which must be made to the work as a whole is its
offensive lack of repose. All the individual details are, with few
happy exceptions, realistic, whilst the effect of the whole composition
moves in extreme unreality. How has Bartholomé’s most original artistic
instinct not preserved him from trying to present a wholly ideal dogma
with the most vulgar, petty realism? Simple mediæval sculptors might
work thus. In our contemporaries we do not believe in simplicity, and
therefore the discord between idea and form has a jarring effect.
The most ideal dogma that Bartholomé preaches is, however, that of
the immortality of the soul and the resurrection of the body; for
his monument can mean only that, if it means anything at all. It is
conceived as a consolation to the sorrow-laden who form the last escort
to a dear one that is dead, or are making a pilgrimage to the grave
of one they loved. And what consolation has he to offer them? See, he
says, in the figures on the upper story, the sorrow with which men
approach the gates of shadow-land. Why this faint-heartedness? Why this
timorous shrinking from the terrors of death? Death has no terrors.
It is entering into peace and the fulfilment of a high promise. And
he shows, in the lower story, the gentle, blessed rest the dead enjoy
who there slumber until their resurrection, watched by their guardian
angel, who awakes them at the appointed hour, and convey their immortal
souls to their divine destination.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account