The tendency is a very natural one, as knowledge of structure
increases, to ascribe particular virtues to the material structures
themselves, and the error is one into which the disciple is likely to
fall, but of which we need not suspect the master-mind. The dynamical
aspect of the case was in all probability kept well in view by those
who, like Goodsir himself, first attacked the problem of the cell and
originated our conceptions of its nature and functions.
But if we speak, as Weismann and others speak, of an “hereditary
_substance_,” a substance which is split off from the parent-body, and
which hands on to the new generation the characteristics of the old,
we can only justify our mode of speech by the assumption that that
particular portion of matter is the essential vehicle of a particular
charge or distribution of energy, in which is involved the capability
of producing motion, or of doing “work.”
For, as Newton said, to tell us that a thing “is endowed with an occult
specific quality, by which it acts and produces manifest effects, is
to tell us nothing; but to derive two or three general principles of
motion[203] from phenomena would be a very great step in philosophy,
though the causes of these principles were not yet discovered.” The
_things_ which we see in the cell are less important than the _actions_
which we recognise in the cell; and these latter we must especially
scrutinize, in the hope of discovering how far they may be attributed
to the simple and well-known physical forces, and how far they be
relevant or irrelevant to the phenomena which we associate with, and
deem essential to, the manifestation of _life_. It may be that in this
way we shall in time draw nigh to the recognition of a specific and
ultimate residuum. {159}
And lacking, as we still do lack, direct knowledge of the actual forces
inherent in the cell, we may yet learn something of their distribution,
if not also of their nature, from the outward and inward configuration
of the cell, and from the changes taking place in this configuration;
that is to say from the movements of matter, the kinetic phenomena,
which the forces in action set up.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account