Ontology, or the Theory of BeingCoffey, P. (Peter)
Philosophy
Ontology, or the Theory of Being
Coffey, P. (Peter)
Ontology
Of course, if conceptually distinct thought-objects are seen to be
mutually incompatible they cannot be found realized except in
really distinct individuals: the union of them is only an _ens
rationis_. Again it may be that the intellect is unable to
pronounce positively as to whether they are compatible or not
(18): as to whether the complex forms a possible being or not. But
when the intellect positively sees such thought-objects to be
mutually compatible—by interpretation of, and inference from, its
actual sense experience of them as embodied in individuals
(18)—and when, furthermore, it now finds a number of them
co-existing in some one actual individual, the question recurs:
How can it know whether they are _really distinct_ from each
other, though actually united to form one (essentially or
accidentally composite) individual, or only conceptually distinct
aspects of one (simple) individual [27 (_b_)]?
This, as we have seen already, is the case for which it is really
difficult to find a satisfactory test: and hence the different
views to be found among scholastic philosophers as to the nature
of the distinctions which the mind makes or discovers _within the
individual_. The difficulty is this. The conceptual distinction
between compatible thought-objects is not a proof of real
distinction when these thought-objects are found united in _one
individual_ of sense experience, as _e.g._ animality and
rationality in man; and the only distinction given to us by sense
experience, at least directly and immediately, as undoubtedly
real, is the distinction _between_ corporeal _individuals_
existing apart in space or time, as _e.g._ between man and man.
How then, can we show that any distinctions _within the
individual_ are real?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account