Outlines of a Critical Theory of EthicsDewey, John
Philosophy
Outlines of a Critical Theory of Ethics
Dewey, John
Ethics
2. The system of social conduct, or common good. Moral conduct springs
from the faith that all right action is social and its purpose is
to justify this faith by working out the social values involved. The
term 'moral community' can mean only a unity of action, made what it
is by the co-operating activities of diverse individuals. There is
unity in the work of a factory, not in spite of, but _because of_ the
division of labor. Each workman forms the unity not by doing the same
that everybody else does, or by trying to do the whole, but by doing
his specific part. The unity is the one activity which their varied
activities make. And so it is with the moral activity of society and
the activities of individuals. The more individualized the functions,
the more perfect the unity. (See section LII.)
The exercise of function by an agent serves, then, both to define and
to unite him. It makes him a _distinct_ social member at the same time
that it makes him a _member_. Possession of peculiar capacities, and
special surroundings mark one person off from another and make him
an individual; and the due adjustment of capacities to surroundings
(in the exercise of function) effects, therefore, the realization of
individuality--the realization of what we specifically are as distinct
from others. At the same time, this distinction is not isolation;
the exercise of function is the performing of a special _service_
without which the social whole is defective. Individuality means
not separation, but defined position in a whole; special aptitude in
constituting the whole.
We are now in a position to take up the consideration of the two other
fundamental ethical conceptions--obligation and freedom. These ideas
answer respectively to the two sides of the exercise of function. On
the one hand, the performing of a function realizes the social whole.
Man is thus 'bound' by the relations necessary to constitute this
whole. He is subject to the conditions which the existence and growth
of the social unity impose. He is, in a word, under _obligation_; the
performance of his function is duty owed to the community of which he
is a member.
But on the other hand, activity in the way of function realizes the
individual; it is what makes him an individual, or distinct person.
In the performance of his own function the agent satisfies his own
interests and gains power. In it is found his _freedom_.
Obligation thus corresponds to the _social_ satisfaction, freedom to
the _self_-satisfaction, involved in the exercise of function; and
they can no more be separated from each other than the correlative
satisfaction can be. One has to realize himself as a member of a
community. In this fact are found both freedom and duty.
CHAPTER II.--THE IDEA OF OBLIGATION.
XLII.
Theories Regarding Moral Authority.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account