I made some explanations to The Teacups, the other evening, which they
received very intelligently and graciously, as I have no doubt the
readers of these reports of mine will receive them. If the reader will
turn back to the end of the fourth number of these papers, he will find
certain lines entitled, “Cacoethes Scribendi.” They were said to have
been taken from the usual receptacle of the verses which are contributed
by The Teacups, and, though the fact was not mentioned, were of my own
composition. I found them in manuscript in my drawer, and as my subject
had naturally suggested the train of thought they carried out into
extravagance, I printed them. At the same time they sounded very
natural, as we say, and I felt as if I had published them somewhere or
other before; but I could find no evidence of it, and so I ventured to
have them put in type.
And here I wish to take breath for a short, separate paragraph. I have
often felt, after writing a line which pleased me more than common, that
it was not new, and perhaps was not my own. I have very rarely, however,
found such a coincidence in ideas or expression as would be enough to
justify an accusation of unconscious plagiarism,--conscious plagiarism
is not my particular failing. I therefore say my say, set down my
thought, print my line, and do not heed the suspicion that I may not
be as original as I supposed, in the passage I have been writing. My
experience may be worth something to a modest young writer, and so
I have interrupted what I was about to say by intercalating this
paragraph.
In this instance my telltale suspicion had not been at fault. I had
printed those same lines, years ago, in “The Contributors' Club,” to
which I have rarely sent any of my prose or verse. Nobody but the
editor has noticed the fact, so far as I know. This is consoling, or
mortifying, I hardly know which. I suppose one has a right to plagiarize
from himself, but he does not want to present his work as fresh from the
workshop when it has been long standing in his neighbor's shop-window.
But I have just received a letter from a brother of the late Henry
Howard Brownell, the poet of the Bay Fight and the River Fight, in
which he quotes a passage from an old book, “A Heroine, Adventures of
Cherubina,” which might well have suggested my own lines, if I had
ever seen it. I have not the slightest recollection of the book or the
passage. I think its liveliness and “local color” will make it
please the reader, as it pleases me, more than my own more prosaic
extravagances:
LINES TO A PRETTY LITTLE MAID OF MAMMA'S.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account