Overtones, a book of temperaments : $b Richard Strauss, Parsifal, Verdi, Balzac, Flaubert, Nietzsche, and TurgénieffHuneker, James
Philosophy
Overtones, a book of temperaments : $b Richard Strauss, Parsifal, Verdi, Balzac, Flaubert, Nietzsche, and Turgénieff
Huneker, James
Music
Nietzsche died August 28, 1900, literally the _Morgenröthe_ of the
new century. It was at Weimar, once the home of Goethe and Liszt.
Nietzsche was in an insane asylum from 1888. Dr. Hermann Turck
asserts that his work was done during a comparatively sane interval
between two incarcerations. In 1868 he met Richard Wagner, and under
the spell of his synthetic genius he wrote Die Geburt der Tragödie
aus dem Geist der Musik, and dedicated it to Wagner, his “sublime
forerunner.” Every line of it, he declares in the preface, was
“conceived in close communion with Wagner.” And let those who know
only the later Nietzsche casually read this essay to be convinced of
its sanity, its acuity, its penetrating originality. Here we find
the enthusiastic, impetuous youth, fresh from his Grecian studies,
a valiant champion of Hellenistic culture, an opponent of the
orientalization of modern life and thought. Twelve years later he
discovered in Parsifal this very despised orientalization, and did
not hesitate to say so in The Wagner Case, that fatal illustration of
George Moore’s pithy axiom: When we change our opinions we change our
friends.
The man who marshalled in the most deadly array of attack his
arguments against Wagnerism is also the man who wrote the most
brilliant book of all on Wagner. Richard Wagner in Bayreuth is
a masterpiece of critical rhapsody. The sister who nursed the
sick-brained man for twelve years, Frau Friedrich Förster-Nietzsche,
tells the story of the dissensions in this friendship, a friendship
that could have endured only through a miracle. Both men had “nerves”
in a highly irritable condition; and, while Wagner had weathered the
storm and had, perforce, developed a stout integument of disdain,
Nietzsche had always remained the sensitive, morbid, cloistered
student. There is no doubt that Richard Wagner, at the triumphant
culmination of his life-work, was an arrogant, exacting, and jealous
being. Wahnfried was, as it now is, a Star Chamber, where the
_Vehmgericht_ judged swiftly, fiercely. Here is one story told by the
sister and quoted by H. E. Krehbiel in his too brief review of the
episode:—
My brother and I heard the Triumphlied of Brahms in the Bâle
Cathedral. It was a splendid performance and pleased Fritz very
much. When he went to Bayreuth in August, he took the pianoforte
arrangement with him, apparently in the naïve belief that Wagner
would like it. I say “apparently,” for upon later reflection it has
occurred to me that this red-bound Triumphlied was meant as a sort
of goad, and therefore Wagner’s prodigious wrath seems to have been
not altogether groundless. So I will leave the continuation of the
tale to Wagner, who had an exquisite fashion of satirizing himself:—
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account