Paul and his interpreters : $b A critical historySchweitzer, Albert
Religion
Paul and his interpreters : $b A critical history
Schweitzer, Albert
Bible. Epistles of Paul -- Criticism, interpretation, etc. -- History; Paul, the Apostle, Saint
The Epistle to the Romans has been very extensively
interpolated._(_113_)_ The original writing was addressed to Gentile
readers. The interpolator, on the other hand, has in view readers “who
occupy an Old Testament stand-point.” That is connected with the
far-reaching development which began at Rome after the Neronian
persecution. At that time, as is proved, Völter thinks, by the Epistle
to the Hebrews and the Epistle of Barnabas, together with the first
Epistle of Clement and the _Shepherd_ of Hermas, the Church at Rome
“fell back upon a religious stand-point determined by Old Testament
ideas.” It is this “reduction of Christianity to Jewish Old Testament
religion, modified by Christianity,” that the interpolator is
concerned to combat. In doing so he is forced to enter upon general
speculations regarding the flesh, sin, and the law; in order “to
defend the independence and superiority of Christianity” he develops
an antinomianism, according to which the law had as its sole purpose,
“by intensifying the misery of sin, to prepare men for deliverance
from sin and the law, by the redemption which is in Jesus
Christ.”_(_114_)_
Völter’s work is one of the adroitest performances in the whole field
of Pauline study. It is not only that it represents what is in its own
way a brilliant synthesis between Weisse and the radicals; its main
significance [pg 146] lies in the fact that it breaks off the barren
literary-critical logomachy, and directs attention once more to the
subject-matter.
Steck and van Manen had failed, once they went beyond the simple
registration of inconcinnities in the text; Völter lets the
theological problems have something to say for themselves. He observes
more clearly than any one had stated it before exactly wherein the
complexity of the question of the law consists, and rightly refers it
to the fact that some passages take for granted its observance by the
Jews as unquestionably right and proper, and only seek to maintain the
freedom of the Gentiles in regard to it, whereas others reject it in
principle, in such a way that Paul would be obliged to maintain also
the emancipation of the Jews . . . if the rules of logical inference
are to be applied. As it is, however, there is a want of congruence
between the negative theory and the limitation of the practical
demand.
In an equally thoroughgoing fashion Völter deals with the problems of
Christology and of the doctrine of the Spirit, and eschatology.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account