thing, or, if it so please thee, put its truth to the test of
experience.
First of all the following must be premised:
1. If there are two fluids of different density, the weights of
which respectively are in the ratio G to L; the altitudes of
cylinders of equal weight, and having the same base, will be in
the ratio L to G.
2. Therefore, if the altitude A C of one fluid contained in the
vessel A D to be the altitude E F of the other fluid contained in
an open tube, as L to D; the fluids so placed will remain at rest.
[Illustration]
3. Therefore, if A C to E F be in a greater ratio than L to
G, the fluid in the tube will ascend; or if the tube be not
sufficiently long, the fluid will escape by the orifice E. (These
are proved by Hydrostatics.)
4. It is possible to have two fluids of different gravity, which
are capable of being mixed one with the other.
5. It is possible to have a filter, strainer or other separator,
by means of which the lighter fluid may be separated from the
heavier.
_Construction_
These being pre-supposed, I construct Perpetual Motion in the
following manner:
Let two fluids of different gravity and capable of mixing
together (which is possible by Hyp. 4) be taken in any
quantities, in equal quantities, if desired; let the ratios of
their gravities be first determined, which suppose as G to L, the
heavier to the lighter; and being mixed, let a vessel, A D, be
filled to A.
This having been done, let a tube be taken, open at both ends
E F; and of such a length that A C : E F > 2 L : G + L; and
the orifice F stopped, or rather filled with a filter or some
substance separating the lighter fluid from the heavier (as is
possible also by Hyp. 5); when the tube filled in this manner
with fluid is immersed to the bottom of the vessel C D; I say
that the fluid will continually ascend by the orifice of the tube
F, and by the orifice E will fall into the fluid below.
_Demonstration_
Because the orifice of the tube F is occupied by a filter (by
Constr.) which separates the lighter fluid from the heavier;
it follows, that if the tube be immersed to the bottom of
the vessel, the fluid lighter by itself, which is mixed with
the heavier fluid, must ascend in the tube, and as it will
ascend above the surface of the surrounding fluid as A C :
E F = 2 L : G + L : which is (by Const.) A C : E F > 2 L :
G + L, it necessarily follows (by Hyp. 3) that the lighter
liquid, through the orifice E, will fall in the vessel below;
there it again mixes with the heavier (by Hyp. 4); and then,
penetrating the filter, ascends again into the tube, and escapes
by the upper orifice. So, therefore, the flow is continued
perpetually.--Q. E. D.
_Corollary_
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account