Physician and patient : $b or, a practical view of the mutual duties, relations and interests of the medical profession and the communityHooker, Worthington
Science
Physician and patient : $b or, a practical view of the mutual duties, relations and interests of the medical profession and the community
Hooker, Worthington
Medical ethics; Physician and patient; Physicians; Quacks and quackery
But there is another still more effectual obstacle, which prevents
the public from making this selection with any degree of correctness.
It is found in the representations, which are made by different
physicians and empirics, of the cases under their care. There is
great difference in physicians in regard to the degree of hope
which they indulge in relation to their patients. One who is apt to
be desponding will, from this cause, make such representations of
the cases under his care, as will create the impression, that his
patients are much more gravely sick, than those that are quite as
sick under the care of another physician, who has a strong tendency
to hope. And besides this, some make willful misrepresentations for
their own selfish ends. A very common artifice, for the purpose of
gaining credit, is to make great cases out of small ones. This is
easily done. I will suppose a case. A child is taken sick, and the
parents are full of anxiety. The physician sees at once that the case
is not at present a grave one, and that remedies will probably in a
short time give relief. If he be honest he will say so, and remove
the undue anxiety of the parents. But if he be disposed, as many
are, to make capital out of the anxieties of his employers, he will
say that the child _is_ very sick, and perhaps that ‘it is well you
have called me so soon,’ or, ‘I wish that you had called me before,
but I think on the whole that the little one _can_ be relieved.’
Every physician knows how readily the imagination of a parent may be
excited in relation to the symptoms of disease in a darling child. He
has seen things believed to be true, under the influence of such an
excitement, which have not the slightest foundation. How easy is it
then in such a case to practice deception, or at least to leave the
parents to deceive themselves with the figments of their own fancy.
If the physician manage adroitly, his skill will be proclaimed with
all the zeal which gratitude for a restored child can prompt. How
dishonest, how _cruel_ is such a course! For the sake of his own
reputation, he has given poignancy to the pangs of anxiety in the
bosom of fond parents, when it was plainly his duty to quiet their
fears, by telling them the true nature of the case.[26]
The physician who practises such deception is indeed occasionally
detected; but if he have tact enough to avoid being _often_ detected,
and if he have effrontery enough to face down those who see through
his arts, such occasional detection is but a small hindrance to
success. In the case which I have supposed, the friends of the
physician of course would claim for him, that there really was
danger, and that he had the sagacity to see what common eyes could
not. And the parents of the child would be very slow to believe that
all their fear and anxiety were unfounded. Their pride, if nothing
else, would prevent them from admitting this to be true.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account