Physician and patient : $b or, a practical view of the mutual duties, relations and interests of the medical profession and the communityHooker, Worthington
Science
Physician and patient : $b or, a practical view of the mutual duties, relations and interests of the medical profession and the community
Hooker, Worthington
Medical ethics; Physician and patient; Physicians; Quacks and quackery
These general facts are sometimes termed principles or laws, and
are sometimes spoken of as the relationships of facts. A theory, or
hypothesis, consists in a supposition of relationships which have
not yet been ascertained. Thus Newton, after discovering the great
general fact of gravitation, supposed that there might be a sort of
ether connecting bodies together, and acting as the medium of their
attraction. This supposition of a relationship, or general fact, not
yet ascertained, is a theory or hypothesis. So when Stahl supposed
the principle called the _vis medicatrix naturæ_ to be in the soul,
and when Cullen supposed that it exists in the nerves and produces
in fever a spasm of the extreme vessels, they both put forth a mere
theory. Cullen speaks of Stahl’s theory as being fanciful. It is so.
But Cullen’s is just as fanciful, if by this word it is meant that it
is unsubstantiated by fact. Cullen’s supposition is more plausible,
it is true, than Stahl’s; but it is no nearer being a proved fact.
There is often much indefiniteness in the use of the word _theory_.
Thus the doctrine, or law of gravitation, as discovered by Newton is
sometimes spoken of as his _theory_ of gravitation. It was _once_
his theory; that is, when it was a mere supposition in his mind. But
when, by a series of observations it came to be a proved fact, it
was no longer a theory. So the laws of the circulation of the blood,
as discovered by Harvey, are sometimes erroneously spoken of as his
theory of the circulation.
Some theories are said to be founded on facts, while others are
deemed to be very fanciful. But theory can never be said, strictly
speaking, to be founded on facts. It has relation to facts, it is
true, but in the attempt to explain their nature, it goes _beyond_
them over into the domain of conjecture.
Every one who puts forth a theory, is apt to think that all previous
theories are false, while his is proved to be conformable to facts.
Dr. Cullen, in announcing his theory, or doctrine (as he styles
it) of fever, which is from beginning to end a series of unproved
assertions, says, “I flatter myself that I have avoided hypothesis,
and what have been called theories.” So Dr. Rush, after framing a
theory even more palpably fanciful, says, that he conceives the
doctrine of fever that he has aimed to establish rests upon facts
only.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account