Physician and patient : $b or, a practical view of the mutual duties, relations and interests of the medical profession and the communityHooker, Worthington
Science
Physician and patient : $b or, a practical view of the mutual duties, relations and interests of the medical profession and the community
Hooker, Worthington
Medical ethics; Physician and patient; Physicians; Quacks and quackery
The quack aware of the prevalence of this superficial knowledge of
medicine, gathered from popular books and lectures, often makes
provision for the taste thus engendered. He hires some one, perhaps
a medical student, to prepare for him a disquisition on some of the
principles of medical science, which is to accompany the certificates
setting forth the virtues of his nostrums. This disquisition may
all be correct, though it is more commonly a mixture of truth and
fallacy, so combined, that the superficial reader does not separate
the one from the other. It answers the purpose for which it is
intended. It convinces most people who read it, that the author (whom
they suppose to be the proprietor of the medicines) really has a
great knowledge of medical science, and that, therefore, though other
patent medicines may be impositions, his cannot be. There is often in
these disquisitions page after page of physiological discussions, in
learned guise, which have no sort of bearing upon the nature of the
medicines recommended, though they do have most manifestly upon their
_sale_, as the result shows.
Let me not be understood to mean, that none but physicians ought
to know anything about the human system; nor that the knowledge of
it, which is obtained from popular books and lectures, can be of no
advantage in the warfare with empiricism. Though, when it is relied
upon as the chief, almost the only, weapon in this warfare, it is,
as you have seen, of little avail, and is often even turned against
the cause of truth and science; yet, as an _adjuvant_ to other means
in removing quackery, it may prove very valuable. What then, let us
enquire, are those other means?
I have shown in another chapter, that the principal popular errors
in medicine arise from partial views of the operations of disease
and the effects of remedies, and are false conclusions in regard to
the relation of cause and effect. These false conclusions are, as
you have seen, the basis of quackery; and therefore one of the chief
means of removing quackery is to be found in the exposure of the
fallacy of these conclusions.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account