Physician and patient : $b or, a practical view of the mutual duties, relations and interests of the medical profession and the communityHooker, Worthington
Science
Physician and patient : $b or, a practical view of the mutual duties, relations and interests of the medical profession and the community
Hooker, Worthington
Medical ethics; Physician and patient; Physicians; Quacks and quackery
One very common mistake in the mental management of some chronic
cases remains to be noticed. I refer to those cases in which the
nervous system is so deranged, as to produce a variety of sensations
of a deceptive character. Such patients are generally laughed at as
hypochondriacs, and they are told by their friends, and sometimes
even by physicians, that these sensations are wholly imaginary. This
is not so. Some of their notions about them are mere imaginations,
it is true; but the sensations themselves are, to some extent at
least, real. Imagination may magnify them, but it does not ordinarily
create them. The wrong ground which is so often taken in regard to
such patients, sometimes essentially retards their recovery. They
feel that they are trifled with, and they have but little confidence
in the judgment of those who deny that their sensations are real,
and therefore have but little if any in the remedies which they
administer to them. Besides, the mind of the patient is disturbed
continually by the disputes and consequent ill feeling which such
differences of opinion necessarily engender, and this of course has a
tendency to aggravate the diseased condition.
As an illustration of these remarks, I will mention a single case.
The patient, who had long been an invalid, had, among a great variety
of sensations, a burning, twinging, sometimes a pulling sensation,
in the region of the stomach. Her notion about it was that there was
a cancer there, that really pulled, and burned, and twinged. She had
been assured again and again that there was no cancer there, but so
little credit had been given to her account of her sensations by
those who had told her so, that she had on her part given little
credit to their knowledge of her case. I immediately told her that
I had no doubt that the nerves in that part of the body were the
seat of the sensations she described, but that she was wrong in the
disease which she fancied to be the cause of those sensations. By
taking this plain and obviously proper ground with her as to the
nature of her case, making the true distinction between what was real
and what was imagined, she was induced to give up the imaginary
notion that was weighing down her spirits. This view of her case,
so consonant with the faithful report of her own sensations from
day to day, commended itself to her common sense, and by inspiring
confidence and hope, did quite as much for her recovery as any other
remedial means that were used.
Among the great variety of topics which have suggested themselves in
connection with the subject of this chapter I have selected those,
the discussion and illustration of which would most interest and
profit the general reader. There are two topics, however, of this
character which require so extended a notice, that I shall devote
to each of them a separate chapter. I refer to insanity, and the
influence of hope in the treatment of disease.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account