Physician and patient : $b or, a practical view of the mutual duties, relations and interests of the medical profession and the communityHooker, Worthington
Science
Physician and patient : $b or, a practical view of the mutual duties, relations and interests of the medical profession and the community
Hooker, Worthington
Medical ethics; Physician and patient; Physicians; Quacks and quackery
In chronic cases, which are going on gradually to a fatal
termination, there sometimes occurs either a temporary pause in the
onward course of the disease, or an alleviation of the symptoms of so
decided a character, that the patient and the physician cannot avoid
indulging for the moment the hope of a recovery. At such times the
bosom of the physician is the seat of conflicting hopes and fears. He
hardly dares to hope, when he calmly surveys the whole case from the
beginning. And yet he has known, he has himself _seen_ some strange
recoveries, perhaps even more strange than such a result would be
in the case before him. What now is his duty to his patient? Shall
he tell him the worst, as it is expressed, and thus extinguish his
rising hopes? Shall he say to him, “This very probably is only a
truce for a little while, and then your now dormant disease will
renew its attack, and perhaps with more vehemence; and, even at
this time, it may be secretly carrying on the work of destruction,
while the remedies are merely administering to your comfort, and
smoothing your passage to the tomb?” To say nothing of the evil of
such a course, if the case be susceptible of a cure, it cannot be an
advisable one, if the prolongation of life and the alleviation of
suffering be objects worthy of the aim of the physician; for such
a course would in most cases have a strong tendency to defeat the
attainment of these objects. If the friends of the patient deem it
important that such a view of his case should be presented to his
mind, let them take the responsibility of doing it themselves, and
not call upon the physician to do it. Ask not him to come to his
patient with the look and language of despair, and utterly dissever
the idea of hope from the efforts which he makes and the remedies
which he administers. Put no such unnatural, and cheerless, and, I
may add, profitless office upon him.
I remember once being strongly urged to such a course by the friends
of a patient. Whilst apparently going steadily down to the grave,
his symptoms at length became much relieved, and he took some
encouragement from the state of his case. In reply to the inquiry of
his friends, whether I had any hope of his recovery, I frankly said
that I had not, and that from all I could see I supposed that the
relief which he experienced was to last but a short time, and that he
must die very soon. They urged me to tell him so, but I declined, for
the reasons that I have stated above. The condition of comfort and
relief lasted in this case, contrary to my expectation, for several
weeks; and they were weeks of delightful intercourse, of affectionate
counsel, and of triumphant faith and joy. And I have not a doubt that
his life was thus happily prolonged in part by the cordial influence
of the hope, that the remedies which relieved his distress might
effect a cure.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account