Physician and patient : $b or, a practical view of the mutual duties, relations and interests of the medical profession and the communityHooker, Worthington
Science
Physician and patient : $b or, a practical view of the mutual duties, relations and interests of the medical profession and the community
Hooker, Worthington
Medical ethics; Physician and patient; Physicians; Quacks and quackery
If it be said that this is the result of change of fashion merely,
and that it therefore does not prove that this practice was not
successful, I reply that, though fashion in medicine may sometimes
temporarily prevent the use of a good remedy, it never effects the
entire and continued abandonment of it by medical men. You will
find it always true of remedies and modes of practice which are
really valuable, that though they may not be as fashionable after a
while, as they were when first introduced into notice, and may, from
the fact, that they have been estimated too highly, be for a time
undervalued, they will never be wholly given up by the profession.
Nearly as great stories were told about calomel and digitalis at
first, as were told about the gases of Dr. Beddoes. But while
experience has shown that calomel and digitalis were over estimated,
it has proved that these gases had an entirely false estimate put
upon their remedial powers.
It is thus that the medical profession, corrects by experience the
errors into which it is led by the uncertainty of medical science.
But the community at large pursue a very different course. They never
correct their errors, but only supplant one error by introducing
another. While physicians reject what is found by experience to be
valueless, and retain what is truly valuable, the multitude reject
alike the good and the bad, in making their constant changes from
remedy to remedy, and from system to system. It is mere caprice, and
not a careful discrimination, that leads them to throw aside one
favorite medicine or system, and adopt another.
It is amusing to watch the movements of the community in relation to
quack medicines. Of these there are a multitude constantly appealing
to the credulity of the public. Some of them in some way, acquire a
currency above their fellows, and from the extent to which they are
used, and from the tales of their wonder-working from all quarters
of the land, and from all conditions of life, one would suppose that
these remedies would never go out of use until mankind cease to be
sick. But look again, only a few years after, and these vaunted
medicines have gone out of use, and the flaming advertisements
proclaiming their virtues have disappeared, and other remedies have
taken their places in the public mind, and on the public tongue,
and of course in the public stomach. This process of change in the
prominent remedies before the public, has ever been going on. Take a
single example. A few years ago, almost every invalid was swallowing
the Hygeian pills, from the pauper that purchased them with his
begged pittance, up to lords and ladies, and senators, and generals,
and clergymen. But in a short time, Brandreth’s effulgent glory burst
upon the earth, and the Hygeian orb faded, and glimmered, and sunk to
rise no more. And now Brandreth is rapidly on the decline, giving way
to others who are rising to take his place.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account