Physician and patient : $b or, a practical view of the mutual duties, relations and interests of the medical profession and the communityHooker, Worthington
Science
Physician and patient : $b or, a practical view of the mutual duties, relations and interests of the medical profession and the community
Hooker, Worthington
Medical ethics; Physician and patient; Physicians; Quacks and quackery
In this account it is stated that the published cases of cures by
the Tractors up to March, 1802, amounted to about five thousand.
“Supposing,” the author goes on to say, “that not more that one
cure in three hundred, which the Tractors have performed has been
published, and the proportion is probably much greater, it will be
seen that the number, to March, 1802, will have exceeded one million
five hundred thousand. It is believed that no medical remedy ever
yet discovered has been supported by so many well-authenticated and
important cures, performed in so short a time.”
And now, I ask, where is the Perkinean Institution, with its troop
of governors for life, and where is the Perkinean practice, with
its list of five thousand published cures? The institution expired
while the governors for life were almost to a man in the land of the
living; and in less than ten years after the summing up of the five
thousand cures, Perkinism was only thought of as a thing that was
past, and the far-famed Tractors were almost forgotten.
And what became of Benjamin Douglass Perkins, who suffered for the
cause of science and humanity such persecution as Galileo and Harvey
and Jenner suffered before him? He returned to his native land with
ten thousand pounds of John Bull’s money, as a reward of his patient
endurance of persecution, and his active benevolence!
I might extend this notice of names which have been famous in the
history of quackery, but it is not necessary. Those which I have
noticed will answer as illustrations of the mode in which medical
delusions obtain their hold upon the public mind, and of the
facility with which each in its turn is supplanted by some other.
The essential materials of quackery, as I remarked in the Preface,
have been the same in all ages; and its history would be only a
description of the endless forms into which these materials have been
moulded. Great as is the variety in the series of phantasmagoria
with which quackery has excited the wonder of the world, they have
all been produced upon the same canvas, and by the same old magic
lantern.
And busy and multiform as quackery has been, and lofty as have been
its claims, I know not that it has ever made a _single discovery in
medicine_. It may possibly have _stumbled_ upon some discovery, but
I am not aware that it has done even this. On the other hand, all
the discoveries which have been made in the medical art, so far as I
know, have been the results of a truly scientific observation, and
fairly belong to that ‘regular’ profession, which so many consider as
being opposed to everything which is new.
FOOTNOTES:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account