Physician and patient : $b or, a practical view of the mutual duties, relations and interests of the medical profession and the communityHooker, Worthington
Science
Physician and patient : $b or, a practical view of the mutual duties, relations and interests of the medical profession and the community
Hooker, Worthington
Medical ethics; Physician and patient; Physicians; Quacks and quackery
In regard to many of the remedies which cure disease, it may be said,
that we know not in what manner they do it. As an example I will
refer to cinchona, and quinine, the essential principle of cinchona,
in curing intermittent fever. The fact that they will cure it in most
cases is as well established as any fact in medicine, but _how_ they
do it no one knows. Many explanations have been ventured, but they
are mere conjectures. Hahneman asserts, that cinchona and quinine
cure intermittent fever on the homœopathic principle, because, as he
declares, he has found, that these articles produce on persons in
health symptoms similar to those of this disease. His experience,
however, does not correspond with that of others, who are more
competent to observe correctly, than one who looks at everything
through the distorting medium of a favorite theory. Cinchona and
quinine have been given to many persons in health, both in large and
in small doses, in order to test the truth of Hahneman’s alleged
experience, and no such results as he describes have followed. They
seem to be singularly confined to Homœopathists.
We see occasionally, but _only occasionally_, effects from agents in
the treatment of disease which seem to have their explanation in the
principle, that one disease is cured by temporarily creating another
similar to it. Hahneman fixed his eye upon these few facts, his mind
became filled with the _one idea_ which he there saw, and he was soon
blind to everything else. Losing thus his mental equilibrium, he
became an errorist precisely in the same way that thousands have done
before him.
The second great principle of Homœopathy is, that a peculiar
power, a ‘dynamic power,’[15] as Hahneman calls it, is communicated
to medicinal substances by minute division, with agitation and
trituration. This Hahneman considers as his grand discovery. This was
wholly an original idea with him, and if it be a really discovered
_fact_ that a peculiar power is thus given to medicines, the credit
belongs to him, and to him alone.
The minuteness of the subdivision prescribed by Hahneman is extreme.
He does not talk of doses so large as the millionth part of a
grain—this would be horribly disastrous. A hundred millionth of a
grain is quite a formidable dose. A decillionth is the common dose,
and this numeral is expressed, after the old method of enumeration,
by an unit with a string of _sixty_ cyphers. If we suppose the
population of the earth to amount to a thousand millions, a grain,
if taken in the dose of a decillionth of a grain, would supply every
inhabitant of the earth with a septillion of doses. And if each
one should take three decillionths of a grain a day, the present
inhabitants of the earth would require very nearly a sextillion of
years to use up the whole grain.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account