Pilgrimages to the Spas in Pursuit of Health and Recreation: With an inquiry into the comparative merits of different mineral waters: the maladies to which they are applicable, and those in which they are injuriousJohnson, James
Science
Pilgrimages to the Spas in Pursuit of Health and Recreation: With an inquiry into the comparative merits of different mineral waters: the maladies to which they are applicable, and those in which they are injurious
Johnson, James
Balneology; Health resorts; Mineral waters
8. _Education._—It is acknowledged that, in no other country is education
so cheaply and amply provided as in Germany. It is remarked by Dr.
Hawkins, that the _results_ of education in Germany and in England,
are very different. In the _former_, the student is almost entirely
engrossed by the physical and practical sciences—whilst the English
one is very much occupied with theology, morality, classics, poetry,
and rhetoric. “Yet in the end, the Englishman becomes most practical,
and the German the most theoretical and sentimental.” With all due
deference to Dr. Hawkins, I doubt or rather deny the fact, that the
practical _education_ of the German renders him theoretical: or that the
theoretical _education_ of the Englishman makes him practical. Will Dr.
H. maintain that a good education in the physical and practical sciences
would convert an Englishman into a theorist or sentimentalist? No, it
would not. It is not the education, but the different circumstances
in which the two people are placed, after leaving the schools, that
produce the contrast noticed by Dr. Hawkins. A complaint is made that
this facility of education leads to surplus candidates for professional
honours; and the German governments endeavour to divert the aspirants
into other channels than the learned professions. But where is there
_not_ this surplus? In England, where education is expensive enough, the
ranks of the church, bar, and medicine, are crowded to suffocation. Two
causes of this operate in Germany. The cheapness of education—and the
cheapness of living afterwards.—Two or three in England—the redundancy of
population, and the choaking up of the war-channels, those waste-pipes
and safety-valves of society. To these may be added the restless ambition
of the shopocracy to push some of their sons into the carriage from
behind the counter.
A considerable portion of the English consider that education (among the
lower classes) without a particular creed, is worse than no education
at all. The real, though not the acknowledged meaning of this is, that
education, or knowledge, is, in the abstract, or _per se_, an evil rather
than a good. It would be much better to openly and candidly maintain this
doctrine at once, than mystify it under the term “religious instruction,”
that is, instruction combined with a _particular_ creed. An ingenious
casuist might easily shew—perhaps prove—the truth of the anti-education
doctrine. Beginning with the Garden of Eden, he might quote Scripture
that knowledge first
“Brought death into this world, and all our woe.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account