Plutarch's essays and miscellanies, Vol. 3 (of 5) : $b Comprising all his works collected under the title of "Morals"Plutarch
Philosophy
Plutarch's essays and miscellanies, Vol. 3 (of 5) : $b Comprising all his works collected under the title of "Morals"
Plutarch
Classical literature; Essays; Ethics; Philosophy
1. When we supped with Ammonius at Athens, who was then the third time
captain of the city-bands, there was a great noise about the house,
some without doors calling, Captain! Captain! After he had sent his
officers to quiet the tumult, and had dispersed the crowd, we began to
enquire what was the reason that those that are within doors hear those
that are without, but those that are without cannot hear those that are
within as well. And Ammonius said, that Aristotle had given a reason
for that already; for the sound of those within, being carried without
into a large tract of air, grows weaker presently and is lost; but that
which comes in from without is not subject to the like casualty, but is
kept close, and is therefore more easy to be heard. But that seemed a
more difficult question, Why sounds seem greater in the night than in
the day, and yet altogether as clear. For my own part (continued he)
I think Providence hath very wisely contrived that our hearing should
be quickest when our sight can do us very little or no service; for
the air of the “blind and solitary Night,” as Empedocles calls it,
being dark, supplies in the ears that defect of sense which it makes in
the eyes. But since of natural effects we should endeavor to find the
causes, and to discover what are the material and mechanical principles
of things is the proper task of a natural philosopher, who shall first
assist us with a rational account hereof?
2. Boethus began, and said: When I was a novice in letters, I then
made use of geometrical postulates, and assumed as undoubted truths
some undemonstrated suppositions; and now I shall make use of some
propositions which Epicurus hath demonstrated already. Bodies move in
a vacuum, and there are a great many spaces interspersed among the
atoms of the air. Now when the air being rarefied is more extended,
so as to fill the empty space, there are but few vacuities scattered
and interspersed among the particles of matter; but when the atoms of
air are condensed and laid close together, they leave a vast empty
space, convenient and sufficient for other bodies to pass through.
Now the coldness of the night makes such a constipation. Heat opens
and separates the parts of condensed bodies. Therefore bodies that
boil, grow soft, or melt, require a greater space than before; but on
the contrary, the parts of the body that are condensed or freeze are
contracted closer to one another, and leave those vessels and places
from which they retired partly empty. Now the voice, meeting and
striking against a great many bodies in its way, is either altogether
lost or scattered, and very much and very frequently hindered in its
passage; but when it hath a plain and smooth way through an empty
space, and comes to the ear uninterrupted, the passage is so sudden,
that it preserves its articulate distinctness, as well as the words
it carries. You may observe that empty vessels, when knocked, answer
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account