Poine: a study in ancient Greek blood-vengeanceTreston, Hubert Joseph
History
Poine: a study in ancient Greek blood-vengeance
Treston, Hubert Joseph
Criminal law (Greek law); Greece -- Civilization; Greek drama (Tragedy) -- History and criticism; Homicide (Greek law); Vendetta
How comes it then, we may ask, that so many writers regard the evolution
of early Greek blood-vengeance, and a corresponding evolution in the
blood-thirst of the Erinnyes, as a transition from the wild to the
tame, from the fierce to the gentle, from the barbarously savage to the
rationally civilised? The reason is twofold. First of all, previous
writers have not distinguished between the tribally controlled Pelasgians
and the bellicose Achaeans, and have therefore misinterpreted the text
of Homer. Secondly, many writers have regarded the dark age of chaos
of post-Homeric Hesiodic days as a valid picture for early Greece as
a whole. This confusion has not only affected modern writers, but it
also affected the Greeks of historical times. The various legends of
post-Homeric times came to be regarded as a proper medium for the
interpretation of Homeric saga. The Athenians of the Periclean age
were compelled to regard as barbarians their forebears of pre-Draconian
times. It is most important to bear this point in mind, in view of our
subsequent analysis of homicide in Attic tragedy. We do not assert that
all the legends of Attic tragedy are ‘unhistorical.’ We shall see that
in Euripides many legends suggest a reference to a period which we may
describe as Homeric or, at least, pre-Hesiodic, and are so faithful a
reproduction of that age that they must be either attributed to the
most skilful conscious archaising on the part of the dramatist, or
regarded as genuine legends which had been transmitted with the least
possible adulteration. But most of the legends which we find in the Attic
tragedians and in the later epic and prose writers are either adulterated
saga, or inventions framed in imitation of such saga. To base a theory of
social or religious evolution on such legends is obviously to build upon
sand.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account