Poine: a study in ancient Greek blood-vengeanceTreston, Hubert Joseph
History
Poine: a study in ancient Greek blood-vengeance
Treston, Hubert Joseph
Criminal law (Greek law); Greece -- Civilization; Greek drama (Tragedy) -- History and criticism; Homicide (Greek law); Vendetta
It is probable that in Greece the ‘cleansers’ of homicide-guilt were
always ‘priests’ of some kind. Epimenides of Crete purged the city
of Athens on a famous occasion, yet not from murder but rather from
sacrilege[125]; moreover, Müller points out[126] that he was a native of
Phaestus in Crete where there was a very ancient cult of Apollo; hence
Epimenides was more than probably a member of an Apolline sacerdotal
guild. Müller is, however, we think mistaken in regarding purgation for
homicide as the exclusive privilege of Apolline priests. The Euripidean
reference to purgation by a priestess of Artemis which we have just
cited,[127] Athene’s interpretation[128] of the supplication of Orestes
as a supplication for purgation, in the _Eumenides_ of Aeschylus, and
many passages in the _Laws_ of Plato,[129] reveal the error of this
opinion.
The purgation of Orestes by Apollo is described by Aeschylus in the
_Eumenides_. It is no priest or priestess of Olympian or Chthonian gods,
but Apollo himself,[130] the chief of the καθάρσιοι θεοί, who performs
the rite. We cannot interpret the ceremony as the purgation of a wilful
matricide ‘abroad,’ as we think that such purgation was impossible, at
least in historical times.[131] It is the ‘purging’ rather of a deed
which is either justified or extenuated by Apollo’s express command, a
‘purging’ which would normally take place in the slayer’s home-land but
which is here attributed to a divine Delphian purifier either because
Apollo was the patron of the Greek ‘purgation’ system or because the
deed was such that no one could have cleansed it save the god who had
commanded it, or because a Phocian legend made Phocis, not Athens, the
place to which Orestes fled after the slaying of his mother. Orestes
tells[132] Athene that he is not a suppliant for purgation at Athens,
because he has been already ‘purged.’ We may infer from this that a
homicide-exile had not to be ‘purged’ more than once in his changes of
residence abroad, but we think it probable that such ‘extern’ purgation
did not dispense with the need for ‘domestic’ purgation if the exile was
ever permitted to return to his home.[133] Orestes says[134]: ‘There is
a law that the shedder of blood is debarred from human intercourse until
at the hands of a man who purifies from bloodshed the blood of a young
animal has been poured upon him. Long ago have I been thus made clean by
others who live elsewhere, by animal victims beside running water.’
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account