Poine: a study in ancient Greek blood-vengeanceTreston, Hubert Joseph
History
Poine: a study in ancient Greek blood-vengeance
Treston, Hubert Joseph
Criminal law (Greek law); Greece -- Civilization; Greek drama (Tragedy) -- History and criticism; Homicide (Greek law); Vendetta
We shall see, later,[219] what a difficult problem the Homeric saga of
Orestes presented to the legend-makers of the ‘Apolline’ era (750 B.C.
onwards). There was only one means by which the Homeric story could be
retained without assuming an atrocious indifference to kin-slaying on the
part of the Homeric Greeks: namely, by representing the act of Orestes
as in some way justified. But the Apolline code, if we may regard Plato
as a worthy exponent of it, did not admit a plea of justification for
the slaying of a parent in any circumstances. ‘In what other way (than
by death),’ says Plato, ‘would it be right to punish one whom no law
will permit, even in self-defence and in danger of his life, to slay
his father or mother ... and whom (the legislator) will bid to suffer
anything rather than perpetrate such a deed?’[220] We are convinced
that there was one thing, and one thing only, which would have been
accepted by Plato as a justification for such an act, namely, the express
command of Apollo himself. Apollo was the reputed founder of the Attic
Court Delphinium; he was regarded as the initiator of the distinction
between just and unjust slaying[221]: he appointed and controlled the
Exegetae or the Sacred Interpreters of the laws of ‘purgation’[222];
surely his command, impossible to disobey, would have been admitted as
a justification for the deed of Orestes. In the _Eumenides_[223] of
Aeschylus, Orestes says to Apollo: ‘Be thou my witness: show, Apollo,
whether I slew her justly. The fact of slaying I do not deny: do thou
decide whether in thy judgment I slew her justly or not, that I may tell
these judges here.’ And Apollo replies[224]: ‘I am a prophet and will
not deceive: never, in my oracular shrine, have I said aught that Zeus,
the father of Olympian gods, doth not command. Take note, ye judges, of
the value of such a justification.’ So, in the _Electra_ of Sophocles,
Orestes says[225]: ‘When I approached the oracular shrine of Pytho, to
learn whereby I might punish the murderers of my sire, Phoebus made
answer: “No host of shielded warriors, but thine own guileful craft, O
prince, and thine own arm shall deal the death-blow righteously.”’ Even
in the _Orestes_ of Euripides, a drama in which, as we shall see,[226]
the plea of justifiable matricide is almost entirely absent, Orestes
tells the Chorus[227]: ‘Behold! Apollo, who in his palace in mid-earth
gives to mortals oracles most clear, by whom we are entirely guided—him I
obeyed when I slew my mother. ’Twas he who erred, not I. Is it not enough
to remove “pollution” if I transfer the guilt to the god?’
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account