Poine: a study in ancient Greek blood-vengeanceTreston, Hubert Joseph
History
Poine: a study in ancient Greek blood-vengeance
Treston, Hubert Joseph
Criminal law (Greek law); Greece -- Civilization; Greek drama (Tragedy) -- History and criticism; Homicide (Greek law); Vendetta
The reference to the State in this quotation is noteworthy. In such a
reference we find ourselves very far removed from the Homeric saga and
the days of private vengeance! The brand or stigma which is mentioned
is that civic degradation which is known as ἄτιμία. We cannot suppose
that these actual words were recorded in the legend which Aeschylus
follows. The statement is much too long for a real oracle! Did Aeschylus
then derive this sentiment from contemporary Attic life? We have seen
that the pollution-doctrine was closely associated, in Greece, with
the interference of the State in matters of homicide. It follows that
the importation of this doctrine into the Oresteian legend would have
naturally introduced, also, the conception of Orestes as a State
criminal, worthy of State punishment. When once the legend received, so
to speak, this colouring, the general atmosphere of the story would have
suggested such words as are attributed in this quotation to Orestes. We
believe that these words of Orestes are the creation of Aeschylus’ own
mind, but we do not attribute to Aeschylus the creation of the legendary
atmosphere which makes such words intelligible.
There is a subtle suggestion of the clash of clan-feuds which
characterised the transition period of the Dark Ages in the Aeschylean
description of the conflict of viewpoints between the Erinnyes of
Agamemnon and the Erinnyes of Clytaemnestra—a conflict which it is
improbable that Aeschylus invented. The avenging goddesses are conceived
as real beings: they are not mere delusions or ‘extrajections’ of a
distracted mind. We have already referred[34] to Orestes’ fear of the
‘darkling arrow’ which may be hurled at him by the Erinnyes of his
father. On the other side, however, stand the Erinnyes of his mother, who
are equally formidable. Orestes says[35]:
Ah! ah!
What grisly troup come yonder in grey robes,
With Gorgon faces and thick serpent hair
Twisted in writhing coils? I must be gone.
This is no fancy, but a present woe.
I see my mother’s Furies clearly there!
This conflict Apollo, of himself unaided, is unable to avert. But we
shall now see how Apollo and Athene, in conjunction, persuade the Furies
of Clytaemnestra to accept ‘appeasement.’ It was thus, as we conceive
it, that the religion of pollution and political synoekism ultimately
overcame the resistance of the clans to new laws and new gods. It was
thus that, after years of chaos and transition, ghosts came at length to
obey State gods and State laws as in tribal life they obeyed the ‘dooms’
of the tribe.
THE ‘EUMENIDES’
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account