Poine: a study in ancient Greek blood-vengeanceTreston, Hubert Joseph
History
Poine: a study in ancient Greek blood-vengeance
Treston, Hubert Joseph
Criminal law (Greek law); Greece -- Civilization; Greek drama (Tragedy) -- History and criticism; Homicide (Greek law); Vendetta
Begone! I bid you, forth of mine abode!...
Profane not with your presence this fair shrine,
But go where headsmen execute the doom,
Where eyes are gouged, throats gashed, where robbed of prime,
Boys lose all hope of offspring, tender limbs
Are hacked or stoned: where men, impaled alive,
Moan long and bitterly.... Go,
Inhabit, as beseems such form, the den
Of some blood-lapping lion, nor infect
With touch accursed my oracular seat.
Go! herded by no goat-herd, ye fell flock,
Hated of all in Heaven. Away! Depart!
Yet the Erinnyes have not lost all traces of the ghost-cult of primitive
ancestor-worship and fertility-worship. We have already quoted[95] the
magnificent passage in which they promise their blessings to the Attic
land. We are reminded of primitive ancestral ghosts by the words which
Clytaemnestra (herself a ghost) speaks to the Erinnyes[96]:
Much wealth of mine ye have glutted, drink offerings,
Unmixed with wine, tempered to soothe your heart;
And rich burnt offerings at dead of night,
That hour of dread, avoided by all gods.
The conception of the Erinnyes as Titans is established by comparing
their frequent references in this play to Apollo and Athene as ‘younger
gods’[97] with their words applied by Prometheus, in another play, to the
Olympian gods[98]:
Yet who but I to these new deities
Gave and determined each prerogative?
and again[99]:
Young gods, young pride of unproved majesty.
We agree with Müller[100] that the ‘appeasement’ of the Furies and
their transmutation into Semnai Theai was an essential part of the
pre-Aeschylean legend. We have already suggested the forces which
probably contributed to the story of their ‘conversion.’ Beneath the
religious, mythical story of a transference of cult, beneath the story
of the adoption by the Erinnyes of the worship of the Semnai, lurks, we
believe, the echo if not the reality of legal and social evolution. The
‘conversion’ of the Erinnyes, which directly indicates the acceptance, on
the part of non-Athenian avengers, of the verdict of an Athenian homicide
court, symbolises also, in general, the acquiescence of rebellious
clans, which in the seventh century B.C. were deprived of material
retribution in cases of bloodshed, in the new system—the historical
system—of murder-penalties, which we have associated with Apollo and
political synoekism. The cult of the ‘Eumenides,’ who were probably
the ‘Semnai’ under a different name, we need not discuss here. It is a
religious rather than a legal matter. It has been discussed at length by
Verrall,[101] Miss Harrison,[102] Müller,[103] and others, and we do not
see that its elucidation affects in the least the intelligibility of this
play.
THE ‘SUPPLIANTS’ AND THE ‘SEVEN AGAINST THEBES’
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account