Poine: a study in ancient Greek blood-vengeanceTreston, Hubert Joseph
History
Poine: a study in ancient Greek blood-vengeance
Treston, Hubert Joseph
Criminal law (Greek law); Greece -- Civilization; Greek drama (Tragedy) -- History and criticism; Homicide (Greek law); Vendetta
We find a reference to the exile penalty _for kin-slaying_ in Homer.[107]
We are told that Tlepolemus, son of Hercules by Astyocheia, came to Troy
from Rhodes, whither he had fled, because when grown to manhood he had
slain his father’s maternal uncle, an old man, Likymnius, of the stock of
Ares. ‘Then with speed he built ships and gathered much folk together and
went fleeing across the deep, because the other sons and grandsons of the
mighty Hercules threatened him.’ So he came to Rhodes, a wanderer, and
his folk settled by kinship in three tribes and were loved by Zeus.’ Leaf
would probably regard this passage as non-Homeric, since it happens to
occur in the ‘Catalogue’: but this will not vitiate our argument, as the
predominant atmosphere of post-Homeric Greece was, in Leaf’s view, that
of the ‘group-system’ and there was no break in the custom of tribal
wergeld. We may assume[108] that the family of Hercules was Pelasgian.
Homer does not mention the place where the slaying took place, but it
was, possibly, Mycenae, of which Electryon, father of Likymnius, was at
one time king. Likymnius was a half-brother of Alcmene, the mother of
Hercules, whose birth, according to Homer,[109] took place at Thebes.
Likymnius was, therefore, a maternal uncle of Hercules and grand-uncle
of Tlepolemus. In a normal clan the avengers of Likymnius must have
included the brothers of Tlepolemus, since the homicide affected the
whole kindred-group. The case is remarkably similar to that described in
_Beowulf_, and referred to by F. Seebohm,[110] but Beowulf took no part
in the quarrel between his maternal and paternal kindreds and the quarrel
was in violation of tribal usage. This is precisely the kind of event
which would have tested to the utmost the solidarity of the kindred; for
there was a clan law that all the members who were akin either paternally
or maternally had to act together in the avenging of a kinsman. The
murder of Likymnius—who was not a kinsman of Amphitryon, grandfather of
Tlepolemus, but who was akin to Hercules, to Tlepolemus and the brothers
of Tlepolemus—was a crucial test, as it involved a conflict between
loyalty to clan law and loyalty to one’s nearer relatives. When Homer
speaks of the avengers of Likymnius as the ‘sons and grandsons of the
mighty Hercules,’ it does not follow that the family of Hercules were the
sole avengers, but that, as the nearest relatives of Tlepolemus, their
action was the most important, seeing that they were the kinsmen whose
obedience to clan law was most difficult and, therefore, most appreciated.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account